新型动力螺旋小肠镜与单气囊小肠镜在疑似克罗恩病中的诊断率与技术性能比较:一项前瞻性研究(含视频)
该前瞻性研究在2021年3月至12月于一家高容量三级中心比较了单气囊小肠镜(SBE)与新型动力螺旋小肠镜(NMSE)在疑似克罗恩病(CD)患者中的技术成功率、诊断率、最大插入深度(DMI)、操作时间和全小肠镜检查率。共177例患者(37.2%女性,年龄7-75岁)接受201次器械辅助小肠镜。两组诊断率无显著差异,但NMSE在顺行检查近端回肠及更远病变的技术成功率更高、操作时间更短、DMI更深、全小肠镜检查率更高,所有不良事件均为轻度。
要点
- 在疑似CD患者中,NMSE与SBE的诊断率无显著差异(80.8% vs 83.6%,P = .65)。
- 顺行NMSE对近端回肠及更远病变的技术成功率显著高于顺行SBE(81.4% vs 33.3%,P = .007)。
- NMSE的全小肠镜检查率高于SBE(37% vs 0.7%,P < .0001),操作时间更短,DMI更深。
核心结论
- NMSE和SBE在疑似CD的小肠评估中均安全有效;NMSE在小肠更深评估、实现全小肠覆盖和缩短操作时间方面优于SBE。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,于2021年3月至12月在一家高容量三级中心纳入177例疑似CD患者(37.2%女性,年龄7-75岁),共接受201次器械辅助小肠镜(SBE或NMSE)。
主要发现
- 技术成功率为83%(SBE 81.5% vs NMSE 87.3%,P = .61),影响后续管理者为92%(SBE 88.5% vs NMSE 97.8%,P = .2)。
- 顺行NMSE对近端回肠及更远病变的技术成功率为81.4%,顺行SBE为33.3%(P = .007)。
- 诊断率无显著差异(SBE 80.8% vs NMSE 83.6%,P = .65)。
- 中位操作时间在顺行(NMSE 40分钟[范围10-75] vs SBE 60分钟[范围20-180],P < .0001)和逆行(NMSE 25分钟[范围20-60] vs SBE 60分钟[范围20-180],P < .0001)中均为NMSE显著更短。
- 顺行NMSE的中位DMI更高(NMSE 400 cm[范围70-600] vs SBE 180 cm[范围60-430],P < .0001);NMSE全小肠镜检查率更高(37% vs SBE 0.7%,P < .0001);所有不良事件均为轻度。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为NMSE和SBE在疑似CD的小肠评估中均安全有效,NMSE在小肠更深评估、全小肠覆盖和缩短操作时间方面优于SBE。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Both single-balloon enteroscopy (SBE) and the novel motorized spiral enteroscopy (NMSE) are effective techniques for device-assisted enteroscopy (DAE). To date, no study has prospectively compared both modalities in suspected Crohn's disease (CD). METHODS: Patients with suspected CD undergoing either SBE or NMSE between March 2021 and December 2021 in a high-volume tertiary center were prospectively compared for technical success (ability to reach the lesion), diagnostic yield, depth of maximal insertion (DMI), procedure time, and total enteroscopy rates. RESULTS: One hundred seventy-seven patients (37.2% female; aged 7-75 years) with suspected CD underwent 201 DAEs. Technical success was 83% (SBE 81.5% vs NMSE 87.3%, P = .61) and impacted subsequent management in 92% (SBE 88.5% vs NMSE 97.8%, P = .2). Technical success with antegrade NMSE was significantly higher (81.4%) than antegrade SBE (33.3%, P = .007) for lesions in the proximal ileum and beyond. There was no significant difference in the diagnostic yield (SBE 80.8% vs NMSE 83.6%, P = .65). Median procedure time was significantly lower in both antegrade (NMSE, 40 minutes [range, 10-75]; SBE, 60 minutes [range, 20-180]; P < .0001) and retrograde (NMSE, 25 minutes [range, 20-60]; SBE, 60 minutes [range, 20-180]; P < .0001) NMSE. Median DMI was higher with antegrade NMSE (NMSE, 400 cm [range, 70-600]; SBE, 180 cm [range, 60-430]; P < .0001). The total enteroscopy rate was higher with NMSE (37% vs .7% with SBE, P < .0001). All adverse events were mild. CONCLUSIONS: Both NMSE and SBE are safe and effective for small-bowel evaluation in suspected CD. NMSE is superior to SBE with regard to deeper small-bowel evaluation with complete small-bowel coverage and shorter procedure time.
引用
- Pal P, Vishwakarma P, Singh AP, et al. Diagnostic yield and technical performance of the novel motorized spiral enteroscopy compared with single-balloon enteroscopy in suspected Crohn's disease: a prospective study (with video). Gastrointest Endosc. 2022. PMID: 36273601. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2022.10.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。