基于NBI国际结直肠内镜分型的高置信度小息肉光学诊断与病理对照:分析错误以提高诊断准确性
本研究作为DISCARD3前瞻性可行性研究的一部分,对184例高置信度光学诊断(OD)错误进行根因分析,所有病例均经病理二次盲审。184例中133例确认为真OD错误,分为4型,其余51例源于病理需深切片、病理观察者或实验室错误等。结论认为OD错误与内镜医师因素、现有分型系统缺陷及组织学不完整有关,并识别出常被误诊为腺瘤的锯齿状息肉(「假性腺瘤」),提出基于NICE分型的增强算法。
要点
- 184例高置信度OD错误中133例为真OD错误,B型(OD锯齿状、病理腺瘤)最多见,占41.4%。
- 其余51例错误源于病理需深切片(43/184)、病理观察者或实验室错误(7/184)及其他错误(1/184)。
- 基于NICE分型的增强算法被提出,纳入形态学及辅助息肉特征。
核心结论
- OD错误可与内镜医师因素如照片记录不佳、现有分型系统失败及组织学不完整相关。
- 识别出一组使用NICE分型常被误诊为腺瘤的锯齿状息肉(「假性腺瘤」)。
- 提出基于NICE分型、纳入形态学及辅助息肉特征的增强OD算法。
研究设计与样本
- DISCARD3(Detect InSpect ChAracterise Resect and Discard 3)前瞻性可行性研究的一部分。
- 对连续<10 mm小息肉的「切除并丢弃」策略实施与质量保证进行评估。
- 对184例高置信度OD错误进行根因分析,所有病例病理均行二次盲审,持续不一致者进一步深切片复核。
主要发现
- 184例真OD错误中133例被识别并分为4型:A型(OD腺瘤、病理锯齿状)45/133(33.8%)。
- B型(OD锯齿状、病理腺瘤)55/133(41.4%);C型(OD腺瘤、病理正常)19/133(14.3%);D型(OD锯齿状、病理正常)14/133(10.5%)。
- 184例中其余51例错误源于病理需深切片(43/184)、病理观察者或实验室错误(7/184)或其他错误(1/184)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Developments in image-enhancing endoscopy and polyp classification systems have led to a number of gastroenterology societies endorsing an optical diagnosis (OD) approach for small polyps at colonoscopy. In this study we performed a root-cause analysis of ODs to determine the most likely causes of OD error. METHODS: As part of a prospective feasibility study, DISCARD3 (Detect InSpect ChAracterise Resect and Discard 3), evaluating implementation and quality assurance of a "resect and discard" strategy for consecutive small polyps <10 mm, a root-cause analysis of 184 cases of high-confidence OD error was performed. In all cases, histopathology underwent a second blinded review and, where discrepancy persisted, further review with deeper levels. RESULTS: After a root-cause analysis, 133 of 184 true OD errors were identified and classified into 4 types: A (OD, adenoma; histology, serrated), 45/133 (33.8%); B (OD, serrated; histology, adenoma), 55/133 (41.4%); C (OD, adenoma; histology, normal), 19/133 (14.3%); and D (OD, serrated; histology, normal), 14/133 (10.5%). The remaining 51 of 184 errors were because of a pathology error requiring deeper levels (43/184), pathology observer or laboratory error (7/184), or other error (1/184). CONCLUSIONS: OD errors can be related to endoscopist-related factors such as poor photodocumentation, failures of current classification systems, and incomplete histology. We identified a subset of serrated polyps frequently misdiagnosed as adenomas ("pseudoadenomas") using the NBI International Colorectal Endoscopic (NICE) classification. An enhanced algorithm for OD is proposed based on the NICE classification including morphologic and adjunct polyp features.
引用
- Ahmad A, Moorghen M, Wilson A, et al. NBI International Colorectal Endoscopic-derived high-confidence optical diagnosis of small polyps compared with histology: understanding errors to improve diagnostic accuracy. Gastrointest Endosc. 2022. PMID: 36029884. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2022.08.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。