不同人群食管腺癌内镜筛查项目的成本效果比较分析
该研究采用3个独立模拟模型进行成本效果比较分析,针对不同性别和种族组合(白人/黑人,各10万人)评估41种筛查策略。结果显示,白人男性胃食管反流病(GERD)患者在45岁和60岁两次筛查最优;黑人男性GERD患者55岁一次筛查最优;白人女性最优策略为不筛查;黑人女性不筛查最优,因获益极小且部分策略造成净损害。
要点
- 白人男性GERD患者在45岁和60岁两次内镜筛查为最优策略。
- 黑人男性GERD患者55岁一次筛查最优,白人女性最优为不筛查。
- 黑人女性不筛查最优,因获益极小且部分策略造成净损害。
核心结论
- 筛查最优策略因种族和性别而异,白人男性GERD症状者可较现行推荐更密集筛查,女性筛查不具成本效果且对黑人女性可能造成净损害。
研究设计与样本
- 采用3个独立模拟模型进行成本效果比较分析,对每种性别和种族组合(白人/黑人,各10万人)评估41种筛查策略,包括一次性或重复筛查。
主要发现
- 白人男性无筛查预计536例EAC死亡,45岁和60岁两次筛查GERD者为最优;55岁一次筛查全部白人男性在26%的概率敏感性分析运行中为最优。
- 黑人男性无筛查EAC死亡84例,55岁一次筛查GERD者为最优。
- 白人女性无筛查EAC死亡103例,最优策略为不筛查,但55岁一次筛查GERD者在29%的概率敏感性分析运行中为最优。
- 黑人女性EAC死亡29例,不筛查最优,因获益极小且部分策略造成净损害。
关键数值与推荐
- 最优策略定义为效果最高且增量成本效果比低于每质量调整生命年10万美元。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND & AIMS: Guidelines suggest endoscopic screening for esophageal adenocarcinoma (EAC) among individuals with symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and additional risk factors. We aimed to determine at what age to perform screening and whether sex and race should influence the decision. METHODS: We conducted comparative cost-effectiveness analyses using 3 independent simulation models. For each combination of sex and race (White/Black, 100,000 individuals each), we considered 41 screening strategies, including one-time or repeated screening. The optimal strategy was that with the highest effectiveness and an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio <$100,000 per quality-adjusted life-year gained. RESULTS: Among White men, 536 EAC deaths were projected without screening, and screening individuals with GERD twice at ages 45 and 60 years was optimal. Screening the entire White male population once at age 55 years was optimal in 26% of probabilistic sensitivity analysis runs. Black men had fewer EAC deaths without screening (n = 84), and screening those with GERD once at age 55 years was optimal. Although White women had slightly more EAC deaths (n = 103) than Black men, the optimal strategy was no screening, although screening those with GERD once at age 55 years was optimal in 29% of probabilistic sensitivity analysis runs. Black women had a very low burden of EAC deaths (n = 29), and no screening was optimal, as benefits were very small and some strategies caused net harm. CONCLUSIONS: The optimal strategy for screening differs by race and sex. White men with GERD symptoms can potentially be screened more intensely than is recommended currently. Screening women is not cost-effective and may cause net harm for Black women.
引用
- Rubenstein JH, Omidvari AH, Lauren BN, et al. Endoscopic Screening Program for Control of Esophageal Adenocarcinoma in Varied Populations: A Comparative Cost-Effectiveness Analysis. Gastroenterology. 2022. PMID: 35364064. doi:10.1053/j.gastro.2022.03.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。