剪式刀与针式刀在结直肠内镜黏膜下剥离术中的疗效与安全性比较:一项事后倾向性评分匹配分析(含视频)
本研究基于2013年8月至2018年12月11家机构的数据,对2330例患者(2498处病变)行事后倾向性评分匹配分析,比较针式刀与剪式刀在结直肠内镜黏膜下剥离术中的短期结局。匹配后针式刀组814处病变、剪式刀组407处病变。结果显示剪式刀组整块切除率与组织学完全切除率与针式刀组无显著差异,但切除速度较慢,单刀完成率更高,术中穿孔和迟发出血率更低。结论认为剪式刀用于结直肠内镜黏膜下剥离术更安全,但切除速度较针式刀慢。
要点
- 剪式刀组整块切除率98.3%(400/407)与针式刀组96.8%(788/814)无显著差异(P = .1888)。
- 剪式刀组组织学完全切除率95.6%(389/407)与针式刀组95.1%(774/814)无显著差异(P = .7763)。
- 剪式刀组术中穿孔率0.7%(3/407)和迟发出血率0.7%(3/407)均低于针式刀组的2.5%(20/814),P = .0431。
核心结论
- 剪式刀用于结直肠内镜黏膜下剥离术更安全,但与针式刀相比切除速度较慢。
研究设计与样本
- 事后倾向性评分匹配分析,数据来自2013年8月至2018年12月一项11家机构的研究。
- 共2330例患者(2498处病变)接受结直肠内镜黏膜下剥离术,分为针式刀组1923例患者(2067处病变)和剪式刀组407例患者(431处病变)。
- 采用2:1倾向性评分匹配,匹配后针式刀组814处病变(709例患者),剪式刀组407处病变(386例患者)。
主要发现
- 中位切除速度针式刀组为18.3 mm2/min,快于剪式刀组的13.2 mm2/min(P < .0001)。
- 整块切除率针式刀组96.8%(788/814)与剪式刀组98.3%(400/407)无显著差异(P = .1888)。
- 组织学完全切除率针式刀组95.1%(774/814)与剪式刀组95.6%(389/407)无显著差异(P = .7763)。
- 单刀完成切除的病变比例剪式刀组98.5%(401/407)高于针式刀组的43.9%(357/814)(P < .0001)。
- 术中穿孔率和迟发出血率剪式刀组均为0.7%(3/407),低于针式刀组的2.5%(20/814),P = .0431。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Many knives have been developed to improve the efficacy and safety of endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD). We aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of scissor-type knives for colorectal ESD compared with needle-type knives. METHODS: We performed a post-hoc propensity score-matched analysis in an 11-facility study between August 2013 and December 2018. A total of 2330 patients (2498 lesions) who underwent colorectal ESD were divided into needle-type (1923 patients, 2067 lesions) and scissor-type (407 patients, 431 lesions) knife groups. Short-term outcomes were compared between the 2 groups. RESULTS: Two-to-one propensity score-matched analysis identified 814 (709 patients) and 407 (386 patients) lesions in the needle- and scissor-type knife groups, respectively. The median resection speed was significantly faster in the needle-type group (18.3 mm2/min) than in the scissor-type group (13.2 mm2/min, P < .0001), whereas en-bloc and histologic complete resection rates were not significantly different between the needle- and scissor-type groups (96.8% [788/814] vs 98.3% [400/407], P = .1888 and 95.1% [774/814] vs 95.6% [389/407], P = .7763, respectively). The rate of lesions resected using a single knife was significantly higher in the scissor-type group (98.5% [401/407]) than in the needle-type group (43.9% [357/814], P < .0001). Rates of intraoperative perforation and delayed bleeding were significantly lower in the scissor-type group than in the needle-type group (.7% [3/407] vs 2.5% [20/814], P = .0431 for each). CONCLUSIONS: Scissor-type knives are safer for colorectal ESD. However, they are associated with slower resection speeds compared with needle-type knives. (Clinical trial registration number: UMIN000016197.).
引用
- Kuwai T, Oka S, Kamigaichi Y, et al. Efficacy and safety comparison of scissor-type knives with needle-type knives for colorectal endoscopic submucosal dissection: a post-hoc propensity score-matched analysis (with videos). Gastrointest Endosc. 2022. PMID: 35247378. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2022.02.042
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。