随机对照试验中右半结肠退镜视频计算机辅助分析在水交换与空气注入下的息肉检出率与假阳性率
本研究基于比较水交换(WE)与空气注入的随机对照试验,用卷积神经网络CADe分析右半结肠退镜视频。WE组额外息肉检出率(APDR)显著高于空气注入组(30.1% vs 12.3%,P=.001),且粪便和气泡相关每结肠镜假阳性数(FPPC)均显著更低。结果支持CADe与WE优势互补的假设。
要点
- WE组APDR为30.1%(37例),空气注入组为12.3%(15例),差异显著(P=.001)。
- WE组粪便相关FPPC均值1.78(SD 1.67),低于空气注入组2.09(SD 2.09),P=.007。
- WE组气泡相关FPPC均值0.53(SD 0.89),低于空气注入组1.25(SD 2.45),P=.001。
核心结论
- CADe在水交换组的额外息肉检出率显著更高,粪便和气泡相关假阳性数显著更低。
- 结果支持CADe与水交换的优势互补可优化息肉检出的假设。
研究设计与样本
- 基于比较右半结肠空气注入与水交换发现的随机对照试验,编辑并编码退镜期视频。
- CADe采用迁移学习的卷积神经网络;两名盲法有经验内镜医师共识判定额外息肉。
- 分析245段编码结肠镜视频:水交换组123段,空气注入组122段。
主要发现
- 水交换组APDR为37例(30.1%),空气注入组为15例(12.3%),P=.001。
- 粪便相关FPPC均值(标准差)水交换组1.78(1.67),空气注入组2.09(2.09),P=.007。
- 气泡相关FPPC均值(标准差)水交换组0.53(0.89),空气注入组1.25(2.45),P=.001。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Water exchange (WE) improves lesion detection but misses polyps because of human limitations. Computer-aided detection (CADe) identifies additional polyps overlooked by the colonoscopist. Additional polyp detection rate (APDR) is the proportion of patients with at least 1 additional polyp detected by CADe. The number of false positives (because of feces and air bubble) per colonoscopy (FPPC) is a major CADe limitation, which might be reduced by salvage cleaning with WE. We compared the APDR and FPPC by CADe between videos of WE and air insufflation in the right-sided colon. METHODS: CADe used a convolutional neural network with transfer learning. We edited and coded withdrawal-phase videos in a randomized controlled trial that compared right-sided colon findings between air insufflation and WE. Two experienced blinded endoscopists analyzed the CADe-overlaid videos and identified additional polyps by consensus. An artifact triggered by CADe but not considered a polyp by the reviewers was defined as a false positive. The primary outcome was APDR. RESULTS: Two hundred forty-five coded videos of colonoscopies inserted with WE (n = 123) and air insufflation (n = 122) methods were analyzed. The APDR in the WE group was significantly higher (37 [30.1%] vs 15 [12.3%], P = .001). The mean [standard deviation] FPPC related to feces (1.78 [1.67] vs 2.09 [2.09], P = .007) and bubbles (.53 [.89] vs 1.25 [2.45], P = .001) in the WE group were significantly lower. CONCLUSIONS: CADe showed significantly higher APDR and lower number of FPPC related to feces and bubbles in the WE group. The results support the hypothesis that the strengths of CADe and WE complement the weaknesses of each other in optimizing polyp detection.
引用
- Tang CP, Lin TL, Hsieh YH, et al. Polyp detection and false-positive rates by computer-aided analysis of withdrawal-phase videos of colonoscopy of the right-sided colon segment in a randomized controlled trial comparing water exchange and air insufflation. Gastrointest Endosc. 2021. PMID: 34973967. doi:10.1016/j.gie.2021.12.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。