安宁疗护一线员工对与患者及家属讨论预立医疗照护计划的障碍与机会认知
本研究采用目的抽样和半结构式访谈的定性设计,基于COM-B实施科学框架,访谈美国4家非营利安宁疗护机构的51名专业人员(31名临床人员、13名管理者、7名质量改进管理者)。结果显示:能力受跨学科团队协作促进、受自感沟通技能不足抑制;机会出现在入院、病情急性变化或恶化时,但受住院时间短和工作量限制;动机受个体化照护目标促进、受对患者及家属偏好的隐含假设削弱。
要点
- 跨学科团队协作与明确角色分工可促进预立医疗照护计划(ACP)沟通能力。
- 入院时、病情急性变化或恶化是开展ACP讨论的关键机会窗口。
- 住院时间短与工作量预期是阻碍员工投入ACP讨论的环境障碍。
核心结论
- 安宁疗护员工也可能对讨论死亡与临终感到不适,但能识别出有效做法。
- 提升ACP参与行为的方案包括员工培训与示范练习、在安宁疗护之前引入ACP、增加员工队伍多样性以提升文化胜任力。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,采用目的抽样与半结构式访谈,使用ATLAS.ti软件辅助模板分析。
- 受访者为美国4家地理位置不同的非营利安宁疗护机构的51名专业人员,包括31名临床人员、13名管理者和7名质量改进管理者,服务机构覆盖超过2700人。
- 访谈领域源自能力、机会、动机与行为(COM-B)实施科学框架,并额外征集行为改变建议,主题差异经共识协调。
主要发现
- 能力方面:跨学科团队协作和明确的临床员工角色起促进作用,自感缺乏ACP沟通技能起抑制作用。
- 机会方面:ACP讨论机会出现在患者入住安宁疗护、病情急性变化或恶化时。
- 机会相关环境障碍包括患者住院时间短等工作时间限制,以及使临床人员无法花更多时间陪伴患者和家属的工作量预期。
- 动机方面:提供个体化、以患者为中心照护的员工目标起促进作用;对患者和家属偏好的隐含假设削弱了员工开展ACP的动机。
关键数值与推荐
- 员工建议包括培训与示范练习、由临床人员在安宁疗护之前的场景更早引入ACP概念,以及增加员工队伍多样性以反映机构希望覆盖的患者人群并提升文化胜任力。
临床怎么用
- 可围绕入院、病情急性变化或恶化等时机常规启动ACP讨论。
- 通过跨学科团队协作与明确角色分工弥补员工自感沟通技能不足。
- 开展培训与示范练习,并在安宁疗护之前更早引入ACP概念。
- 增加员工队伍多样性并提升文化胜任力,以减少对患者及家属偏好的隐含假设。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To understand the facilitators and barriers to hospice staff engagement of patients and surrogates in advance care planning (ACP) conversations. DESIGN: Qualitative study conducted with purposive sampling and semistructured interviews using ATLAS.ti software to assist with template analysis. SETTINGS AND PARTICIPANTS: Participants included 51 hospice professionals (31 clinicians, 13 leaders, and 7 quality improvement administrators) from 4 geographically distinct nonprofit US hospices serving more than 2700 people. MEASURES: Interview domains were derived from the implementation science framework of Capability, Opportunity, Motivation, and Behavior (COM-B), with additional questions soliciting recommendations for behavior change. Differences in themes were reconciled by consensus. The facilitator, barrier, and recommendation themes were organized within the COM-B framework. RESULTS: Capability was facilitated by interdisciplinary teamwork and specified clinical staff roles and inhibited by lack of self-perceived skill in engaging in ACP conversations. Opportunities for ACP occurred during admission to hospice, acute changes, or deterioration in patient condition. Opportunity-related environmental barriers included time constraints such as short patient stay in hospice and workload expectations that prevented clinicians from spending more time with patients and families. Motivation to discuss ACP was facilitated by the employee's goal of providing personalized, patient-centered care. Implicit assumptions about patients' and families' preferences reduced staff's motivation to engage in ACP. Hospice staff made recommendations to improve ACP discussions, including training and modeling practice sessions, earlier introduction of ACP concepts by clinicians in prehospice settings, and increasing workforce diversity to reflect the patient populations the organizations want to reach and cultural competency. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Even hospice staff can be uncomfortable discussing death and dying. Yet staff were able to identify what worked well. Solutions to increase behavior of ACP engagement included staff training and modeling practice sessions, introducing ACP prior to hospice, and increasing workforce diversity to improve cultural competency.
引用
- Oh A, Allison TA, Mahoney K, et al. Front-Line Hospice Staff Perceptions of Barriers and Opportunities to Discussing Advance Care Planning With Hospice Patients and Their Families. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2021. PMID: 34391713. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2021.07.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。