加拿大老龄化纵向研究中衰弱指数可靠性的临床相关因素与意义
结果显示,FI的项目数量和组成变异会显著影响其可靠性,基于FI的估计可能不够稳定,难以推广或直接应用。
要点
- FI项目数量从5增至45时,ICC从0.19升至0.84,可靠性随项目数增加而提高。
- 不同项目数量和组成下,衰弱患病率中位数从11%降至3%,死亡率OR中位数从1.24升至2.19,变异明显。
- FI预测10%死亡率对应的 cutoff 中位数从0.38降至0.20,稳定性不足。
核心结论
- 衰弱指数项目数量和组成的变异会强烈影响其可靠性,基于FI的估计可能不足以稳定地推广结果或直接应用。
主要发现
- 衰弱评分中位数为0.11-0.12,5项FI的分布范围为0.04-0.24,45项FI为0.10-0.14。
- 识别15%为衰弱的 cutoff 中位数为0.19-0.20且稳定,分布范围随项目数增加而减小。
- 衰弱患病率中位数为11%-3%,死亡率OR中位数为1.24-2.19,预测死亡率概率中位数为8%-17%,预测10%死亡率的FI cutoff中位数为0.38-0.20,均变异明显。
- ICC从5项FI的0.19增至45项FI的0.84。
关键数值与推荐
- 识别15%为衰弱的FI cutoff中位数为0.19-0.20。
- 预测随访期间10%死亡率的FI cutoff中位数范围为0.38-0.20。
- ICC从5项FI的0.19升至45项FI的0.84。
临床怎么用
- 临床使用衰弱指数时应关注其项目数量和组成对评分、患病率及预测稳定性的影响,避免直接套用未经充分验证的FI估计。
局限性
- 原文未报告模拟研究的具体局限性说明。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Deficit accumulation frailty indices (FIs) are widely used to characterize frailty. FIs vary in number and composition of items; the impact of this variation on reliability and clinical applicability is unknown. METHOD: We simulated 12 000 studies using a set of 70 candidate deficits in 12 080 community-dwelling participants 65 years and older. For each study, we varied the number (5, 10, 15, 25, 35, 45) and composition (random selection) of items defining the FI and calculated descriptive and predictive estimates: frailty score, prevalence, frailty cutoff, mortality odds ratio, predicted probability of mortality for FI = 0.28 (prevalence threshold), and FI cutoff predicting 10% mortality over the follow-up. We summarized the estimates' medians and spreads (0.025-0.975 quantiles) by number of items and calculated intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). RESULTS: Medians of frailty scores were 0.11-0.12 with decreasing spreads from 0.04-0.24 to 0.10-0.14 for 5-item and 45-item FIs. The median cutoffs identifying 15% as frail was 0.19-0.20 and stable; the spreads decreased with more items. However, medians and spreads for the prevalence of frailty (median: 11%-3%), mortality odds ratio (median: 1.24-2.19), predicted probability of mortality (median: 8%-17%), and FI cutoff predicting 10% mortality (median: 0.38-0.20) varied markedly. ICC increased from 0.19 (5-item FIs) to 0.84 (45-item FIs). CONCLUSIONS: Variability in the number and composition of items of individual FIs strongly influences their reliability. Estimates using FIs may not be sufficiently stable for generalizing results or direct application. We propose avenues to improve the development, reporting, and interpretation of FIs.
引用
- Nguyen QD, Moodie EM, Keezer MR, et al. Clinical Correlates and Implications of the Reliability of the Frailty Index in the Canadian Longitudinal Study on Aging. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2021. PMID: 34097017. doi:10.1093/gerona/glab161
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。