养老院临终照护中的种族/族裔差异:系统综述
该研究系统综述了养老院临终照护中种族/族裔少数群体居民在预立医疗规划、临终住院、临终关怀使用和疼痛管理等方面的差异。纳入的18篇文章中,大多数质量良好但数据多截至2010年。少数族裔居民较少完成预立医疗指示,黑人居民较少使用临终关怀,西班牙裔和黑人居民更可能经历临终住院,且少数族裔居民疼痛和症状管理更差。
要点
- 少数族裔养老院居民较少完成预立医疗指示。
- 黑人居民在死亡前使用临终关怀的可能性 consistently 较低。
- 西班牙裔和黑人居民比非西班牙裔白人更可能经历临终住院。
核心结论
- 本综述发现养老院在预立医疗规划、临终住院和疼痛管理方面存在种族/族裔健康差异。
- 需要采用反映当前养老院人口趋势的最新数据开展研究。
- 为减少临终差异,少数族裔比例高的养老院应提供语言服务和员工文化能力培训。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,遵循PRISMA指南并在PROSPERO注册(CRD42020181792)。
- 检索三个电子数据库,时间范围为2010年至2020年5月。
- 纳入18篇文章,其中16篇质量良好,15篇使用截至2010年的数据。
- 研究对象为患有终末期疾病或接近临终的老年养老院居民,包括种族/族裔少数群体居民。
主要发现
- 少数族裔居民较少完成预立医疗指示。
- 临终关怀使用情况不一,但黑人居民在死亡前使用临终关怀的可能性 consistently 较低。
- 西班牙裔和黑人居民比非西班牙裔白人居民更可能经历临终住院。
- 少数族裔居民在临终时疼痛和症状管理更差。
- 临终照护差异在黑人居民比例较高的养老院中最为明显。
关键数值与推荐
- 识别出四个结局:预立医疗规划(n=10)、临终关怀(n=8)、临终住院(n=6)和疼痛管理(n=1)。
- 研究对种族/族裔少数群体居民的定义和分组各不相同。
- 没有文章研究姑息治疗的具体内容(如精神关怀)。
临床怎么用
- 在少数族裔比例高的养老院应提供语言服务和员工文化能力培训。
- 关注少数族裔居民的预立医疗指示完成情况和临终关怀使用。
- 监测少数族裔居民的临终住院和疼痛管理差异。
局限性
- 大多数研究使用截至2010年的数据,可能不反映当前养老院人口趋势。
- 研究对种族/族裔少数群体居民的定义和分组存在差异。
- 缺乏对姑息治疗具体内容(如精神关怀)的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Health disparities are pervasive in nursing homes (NHs), but disparities in NH end-of-life (EOL) care (ie, hospital transfers, place of death, hospice use, palliative care, advance care planning) have not been comprehensively synthesized. We aim to identify differences in NH EOL care for racial/ethnic minority residents. DESIGN: A systematic review guided by the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses and registered in PROSPERO (CRD42020181792). SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Older NH residents who were terminally ill or approaching the EOL, including racial/ethnic minority NH residents. METHODS: Three electronic databases were searched from 2010 to May 2020. Quality was assessed using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. RESULTS: Eighteen articles were included, most (n = 16) were good quality and most (n = 15) used data through 2010. Studies varied in definitions and grouping of racial/ethnic minority residents. Four outcomes were identified: advance care planning (n = 10), hospice (n = 8), EOL hospitalizations (n = 6), and pain management (n = 1). Differences in EOL care were most apparent among NHs with higher proportions of Black residents. Racial/ethnic minority residents were less likely to complete advance directives. Although hospice use was mixed, Black residents were consistently less likely to use hospice before death. Hispanic and Black residents were more likely to experience an EOL hospitalization compared with non-Hispanic White residents. Racial/ethnic minority residents experienced worse pain and symptom management at the EOL; however, no articles studied specifics of palliative care (eg, spiritual care). CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: This review identified NH health disparities in advance care planning, EOL hospitalizations, and pain management for racial/ethnic minority residents. Research is needed that uses recent data, reflective of current NH demographic trends. To help reduce EOL disparities, language services and cultural competency training for staff should be available in NHs with higher proportions of racial/ethnic minorities.
引用
- Estrada LV, Agarwal M, Stone PW, et al. Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Nursing Home End-of-Life Care: A Systematic Review. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2021. PMID: 33428892. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2020.12.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。