侧向扰动步态训练与髋肌力强化对社区老年人平衡及跌倒的随机对照研究
该评估者盲法析因随机对照试验比较了扰动诱导步态训练(IST)、髋外展肌力强化(HST)及其组合(CMB)对社区老年人平衡、肌力和12个月前瞻性跌倒的影响。结果显示IST和CMB增加稳定单侧侧步比例,CMB优于对照(率比2.68);HST单独增加髋力矩25%;相对对照,CMB、IST、HST的跌倒率比分别为0.26、0.44、0.30。结论提示扰动联合力量训练对步态平衡改善最佳,干预使未来跌倒较对照减少56%-74%。
要点
- 扰动联合力量训练(CMB)对步态平衡改善优于单纯力量训练。
- CMB较对照使跌倒率降低,率比0.26(95%CI 0.07-0.90)。
- 侧向平衡扰动训练可增强传统跌倒预防方案。
核心结论
- 通过步态训练的平衡表现以扰动联合力量训练改善最佳,而非单纯力量训练。
- 干预使未来跌倒较对照减少56%-74%。
- 侧向平衡扰动训练可能增强传统跌倒预防方案。
研究设计与样本
- 评估者盲法析因随机对照试验,纳入社区居住老年人。
- 受试者随机分为4组:IST(n=25)、HST(n=25)、CMB(n=25)和SFR对照(n=27)。
- 训练共36次,为期12周,训练后随访12个月确定跌倒频率。
主要发现
- 总体恢复步数减少31%,且取决于第一步类型。
- IST和CMB较HST和SFR在训练前后增加更稳定的单侧侧步比例,后两者更多使用多步交叉和连续步。
- CMB的侧步改善率超过对照(CMB/SFR率比2.68)。
- 第一步长度未改变,HST单独使髋力矩增加25%。
- 相对SFR,跌倒率比(跌倒/人/年)[95%CI]为CMB 0.26[0.07-0.90]、IST 0.44[0.18-1.08]、HST 0.30(0.10-0.91)。
关键数值与推荐
- IST组接受43次渐进性扰动。
- 训练共36次,为期12周。
- 跌倒率比(跌倒/人/年)[95%CI]:CMB 0.26[0.07-0.90]、IST 0.44[0.18-1.08]、HST 0.30(0.10-0.91)。
- CMB/SFR侧步率比2.68。
- HST单独使髋力矩增加25%。
临床怎么用
- 对社区老年人跌倒预防,可考虑将侧向平衡扰动训练与髋肌力强化联合应用。
- 单纯髋肌力强化对步态平衡改善有限,联合扰动训练可能更有效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: This factorial, assessor-blinded, randomized, and controlled study compared the effects of perturbation-induced step training (lateral waist-pulls), hip muscle strengthening, and their combination, on balance performance, muscle strength, and prospective falls among older adults. METHODS: Community-dwelling older adults were randomized to 4 training groups. Induced step training (IST, n = 25) involved 43 progressive perturbations. Hip abduction strengthening (HST, n = 25) utilized progressive resistance exercises. Combined training (CMB, n = 25) included IST and HST, and the control performed seated flexibility/relaxation exercises (SFR, n = 27). The training involved 36 sessions for a period of 12 weeks. The primary outcomes were the number of recovery steps and first step length, and maximum hip abduction torque. Fall frequency during 12 months after training was determined. RESULTS: Overall, the number of recovery steps was reduced by 31% and depended upon the first step type. IST and CMB increased the rate of more stable single lateral steps pre- and post-training than HST and SFR who used more multiple crossover and sequential steps. The improved rate of lateral steps for CMB exceeded the control (CMB/SFR rate ratio 2.68). First step length was unchanged, and HST alone increased hip torque by 25%. Relative to SFR, the fall rate ratios (falls/person/year) [95% confidence interval] were CMB 0.26 [0.07-0.90], IST 0.44 [0.18-1.08], and HST 0.30 (0.10-0.91). CONCLUSIONS: Balance performance through stepping was best improved by combining perturbation and strength training and not strengthening alone. The interventions reduced future falls by 56%-74% over the control. Lateral balance perturbation training may enhance traditional programs for fall prevention.
引用
- Rogers MW, Creath RA, Gray V, et al. Comparison of Lateral Perturbation-Induced Step Training and Hip Muscle Strengthening Exercise on Balance and Falls in Community-Dwelling Older Adults: A Blinded Randomized Controlled Trial. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2021. PMID: 33491052. doi:10.1093/gerona/glab017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。