身体衰弱的进展与全因死亡风险:是否存在不可逆点?
采用身体衰弱表型测量衰弱,Cox模型分析衰弱标准数目及累积模式与死亡的关系,Markov状态转换模型分析衰弱发生后年度转换。结果显示衰弱标准数目与死亡风险呈非线性关联,累积全部5项标准后风险显著加速(HR=32.6 vs 无,95%CI=15.7-67.5),但证据不足以宣称存在不可逆点。
要点
- 衰弱标准数目与死亡风险非线性相关,累积全部5项后风险急剧升高。
- 5项衰弱标准者一年死亡风险为3-4项者的3倍,恢复可能性减半。
- 无前期衰弱史直接发生衰弱者死亡风险增加50%(HR=1.51,95%CI=1.20-1.90)。
核心结论
- 衰弱标准数目和累积速率均与死亡风险相关,但证据不足以宣称存在不可逆点。
- 累积全部5项衰弱标准标志着向不可逆点过渡的开始。
研究设计与样本
- 衰弱用身体衰弱表型测量,Cox模型分析衰弱标准数目及累积模式与死亡关系。
- Markov状态转换模型分析衰弱发生后(n=373)年度健康状态(衰弱、恢复、死亡)转换。
主要发现
- 衰弱标准数目与死亡风险呈非线性关联,累积全部5项标准后风险加速(HR=32.6 vs 无,95%CI=15.7-67.5)。
- 5项衰弱标准者一年死亡风险为3-4项者的3倍,恢复(转为稳健或衰弱前期)可能性减半。
- 无前期衰弱史直接发生衰弱者死亡风险增加50%(HR=1.51,95%CI=1.20-1.90)。
关键数值与推荐
- 衰弱标准数目(0-5项)与全因死亡风险非线性相关。
- 累积全部5项衰弱标准后死亡风险HR=32.6(vs 无,95%CI=15.7-67.5)。
- 5项衰弱标准者一年死亡风险为3-4项者的3倍,恢复可能性减半。
- 无前期衰弱史直接发生衰弱者死亡风险HR=1.51(95%CI=1.20-1.90)。
临床怎么用
- 持续监测衰弱进展可辅助临床和个人决策干预时机及向姑息治疗过渡。
- 累积全部5项衰弱标准提示应向患者和照护者沟通预后及照护目标转变。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the rate and patterns of accumulation of frailty manifestations in relationship to all-cause mortality and whether there is a point in the progression of frailty beyond which the process becomes irreversible and death becomes imminent (a.k.a. point of no return). DESIGN: Longitudinal observational study. SETTING: Community or a non-nursing home residential care setting. PARTICIPANTS: Two thousand five hundred and fifty seven robust older adults identified at baseline in 2011 with follow-up for all-cause mortality between 2011 and 2018. MEASUREMENTS: Frailty was measured by the physical frailty phenotype. Cox models were used to study the relationships of the number of frailty criteria (0-5) at each point in time and its accumulation patterns with all-cause mortality. Markov state-transition models were used to study annual transitions between health states (i.e., frailty, recovery, and death) after becoming frail among those with frailty onset (n = 373). RESULTS: There was a nonlinear association between greater number of frailty criteria and increasing risk of mortality, with a notable risk acceleration after having accumulated all five criteria (hazard ratio (HR) = 32.6 vs none, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 15.7-67.5). In addition, the risk of one-year mortality tripled, and the likelihood of recovery (i.e., reverting to be robust or pre-frail) halved among those with five frailty criteria compared to those with three or four criteria. A 50% increase in mortality risk was also associated with frailty onset without (vs with) a prior history of pre-frailty (HR = 1.51, 95% CI = 1.20-1.90). CONCLUSION: Both the number and rate of accumulation of frailty criteria were associated with mortality risk. Although there was insufficient evidence to declare a point of no return, having all five-frailty criteria signals the beginning of a transition toward a point of no return. Ongoing monitoring of frailty progression could aid clinical and personal decision-making regarding timing of intervention and eventual transition from curative to palliative care.
引用
- Xue QL, Bandeen-Roche K, Tian J, et al. Progression of Physical Frailty and the Risk of All-Cause Mortality: Is There a Point of No Return? J Am Geriatr Soc. 2020. PMID: 33368158. doi:10.1111/jgs.16976
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。