医院医生对痴呆患者姑息治疗会诊的决策视角
该描述性定性研究在美国一家全国性非营利医疗系统的7家医院访谈了28名医院医生,探讨其为痴呆患者决定是否请求姑息治疗会诊的影响因素。会诊决策受患者、家庭照护者、医院医生和机构四类因素影响,通常仅考虑晚期患者;时间不足、技能信心不足、家属抵触及机构文化阻碍会诊。
要点
- 会诊多限于晚期、接受激进治疗或家庭沟通需求突出的痴呆患者
- 医院医生时间有限及对姑息治疗技能缺乏信心是请求会诊的重要驱动因素
- 家属抵触或参与照护有限、姑息与临终照护混淆的医院文化构成障碍
核心结论
- 医院医生对痴呆患者是否请求姑息治疗会诊经历复杂的决策过程。
- 需要系统识别最可能从姑息治疗会诊中获益的住院痴呆患者。
- 需要制定策略克服可改变的家庭与机构层面障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 描述性定性研究,采用个人半结构化访谈与主题分析。
- 设置于一家全国性非营利医疗系统内的7家医院。
- 171名医院医生符合参与条件,其中28名(16%)接受访谈。
- 受访者中17名(61%)为男性,16名(57%)为白人,18名(64%)执业不足10年。
主要发现
- 会诊决策受患者、家庭照护者、医院医生和机构四个主题的多重因素影响。
- 会诊通常仅针对晚期患者,尤其是接受激进治疗或存在家庭沟通需求者。
- 家庭沟通需求包括处理治疗目标冲突及改善对疾病与预后的理解。
- 医院医生时间有限及部分对姑息治疗技能缺乏信心是请求会诊的强烈驱动因素。
- 若感知家属抵触或家属照护可用性/参与有限,多数医院医生不会请求会诊。
关键数值与推荐
- 机构层面转诊障碍包括将姑息治疗与临终照护混为一谈的医院文化,以及部分医院姑息治疗团队繁忙。
- 会诊通常仅在患者处于晚期疾病时被考虑。
临床怎么用
- 对住院痴呆患者应系统识别最可能从姑息治疗会诊中获益者,而非仅限晚期或激进治疗者。
- 针对家属抵触与参与不足、机构文化与团队繁忙等可改变障碍设计干预策略。
局限性
- 仅28名(16%)符合条件的医院医生接受访谈,样本可能代表特定观点。
- 研究限于一家全国性非营利医疗系统的7家医院,外推性受限。
- 为定性描述设计,未报告会诊率或结局的定量关联。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: Specialty palliative care for hospitalized patients with dementia is widely recommended and may improve outcomes, yet rates of consultation remain low. We sought to describe hospitalists' decision-making regarding palliative care consultation for patients with dementia. DESIGN: Descriptive qualitative study. SETTING: Seven hospitals within a national nonprofit health system. PARTICIPANTS: Hospitalist physicians. MEASUREMENTS: Individual semistructured interviews. We used thematic analysis to explore factors that influence hospitalists' decision to consult palliative care for patients with dementia. RESULTS: A total of 171 hospitalists were eligible to participate, and 28 (16%) were interviewed; 17 (61%) were male, 16 (57%) were white, and 18 (64%) were in practice less than 10 years. Overall, hospitalists' decisions to consult palliative care for patients with dementia were influenced by multiple factors across four themes: patient, family caregiver, hospitalist, and organization. Consultation was typically only considered for patients with advanced disease, particularly those receiving aggressive care or with family communication needs (navigating conflicts around goals of care and improving disease and prognostic understanding). Hospitalists' limited time and, for some, a lack of confidence in palliative care skills were strong drivers of consultation. Palliative care needs notwithstanding, most hospitalists would not request consultation if they perceived families would be resistant to it or had limited availability or involvement in caregiving. Additional barriers to referral at the organization level included a hospital culture that conflated palliative and end-of-life care and busy palliative care teams at some hospitals. CONCLUSION: Hospitalists described a complex consultation decision process for involving palliative care specialists in the care of patients with dementia. Systematic identification of hospitalized patients with dementia most likely to benefit from palliative care consultation and strategies to overcome modifiable family and organization barriers are needed. J Am Geriatr Soc 68:2365-2372, 2020.
引用
- Courtright KR, Srinivasan TL, Madden VL, et al. "I Don't Have Time to Sit and Talk with Them": Hospitalists' Perspectives on Palliative Care Consultation for Patients with Dementia. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2020. PMID: 32748393. doi:10.1111/jgs.16712
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。