临床伦理委员会在长期住宿照护机构中的作用:一项系统综述
文章描述了长期照护机构中临床伦理委员会的设立目的、角色(前瞻性个案咨询、病例审查、政策制定、伦理教育)、成员构成及可处理的议题,但很少报告法律要求、建议实施情况及效果。结论认为临床伦理委员会有潜力支持解决复杂伦理问题,但需实证研究确定其有效性。
要点
- 长期照护机构中临床伦理委员会通常旨在协助处理伦理问题并改善照护质量。
- 委员会角色包括前瞻性个案咨询、病例审查、政策制定和伦理教育。
- 委员会成员4至20人,常见为护理人员、医生和主任/管理者。
核心结论
- 临床伦理委员会有潜力为长期照护中复杂伦理问题提供有价值的支持,但需实证研究确定其有效性。
主要发现
- 多数文章来自美国,临床伦理委员会设立目的通常为协助处理伦理问题并改善照护质量。
- 委员会角色包括前瞻性个案咨询、病例审查、政策制定和伦理教育,很少报告是否法律要求或明文规定。
- 成员4至20人,最常见为护理人员、医生和主任/管理者,成员构成理由很少描述。
- 个案咨询通常在转介时召集,居民议题包括临终照护决策、自主/自决和医疗决策,工作人员议题包括医疗决策、临终照护决策和决策问题。
- 决策过程各异,会议结果通常为建议,建议和决定的实施很少报告。
临床怎么用
- 长期照护机构可参考综述所述角色和成员构成设立临床伦理委员会,但需注意其建议实施和效果尚缺乏实证数据。
局限性
- 多数文章来自美国,13篇为主要研究,建议实施和委员会有效性很少报告,需进一步实证研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To conduct a systematic review of literature examining the establishment and operation of clinical ethical committees (CECs) in long-term care (LTC). DESIGN: Systematic review. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: LTC recipients/family or staff. METHODS: Five databases (Ovid Medline, Ovid Cochrane Library, Ovid PsycINFO, Ovid EMBASE, and CINAHL via EbscoHost) were systematically searched from their inception to May 8, 2020. The initial search was conducted on August 22, 2017, and updated on May 8, 2020, to identify peer-reviewed studies, commentaries, or editorials. The quality of studies was assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool. RESULTS: Thirty-three articles were identified for inclusion, of which 13 were primary studies. Most articles were set in the United States. The purpose of establishing a CEC in LTC was typically to assist in dealing with ethical issues and improve the quality of care. The articles described the roles of CECs to include prospective case consultation, case review, policy development, and ethics education. Articles rarely reported whether the CEC was required by or enshrined in law. Membership of CECs was between 4 and 20 members and most commonly included nursing staff, physicians, and directors/administrators. The rationale behind the membership was rarely described. For case consultation, articles described that CECs were typically convened upon referral. The resident issues which a CEC could address included end-of-life care decisions, autonomy/self-determination, and medical treatment decisions. The staff issues addressed by CECs included medical treatment decisions, end-of-life care decisions, and decision-making issues. The decision-making process followed by CECs varied. The outcome of a CEC meeting was typically a recommendation, whereas the implementation of CEC recommendations and decisions were rarely reported. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: This systematic review identifies how CECs operate in the LTC setting. CECs have the potential to provide valuable support in addressing complex ethical issues in LTC; however, empirical research is required to determine their efficacy in the LTC setting.
引用
- Holmes AL, Bugeja L, Ibrahim JE, et al. Role of a Clinical Ethics Committee in Residential Aged Long-Term Care Settings: A Systematic Review. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2020. PMID: 32736991. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2020.05.053
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。