多组分安宁疗护项目对养老院居民临终住院与死亡地点无影响
PACE Steps to Success 是一项为期1年的培训者培训项目,旨在通过员工教育和组织支持将非专科安宁疗护整合进养老院。该研究为PACE整群随机对照试验的二次分析,纳入7个欧盟国家78家养老院的死亡数据,比较干预前后居民急诊就诊、住院、住院时长及死亡地点。结果显示项目对上述结局均无统计学显著影响。
要点
- PACE项目未显著改变养老院居民临终前1个月的急诊就诊、住院或住院时长。
- PACE项目未显著改变养老院居民的死亡地点。
- 作者认为无效应可能与部分养老院实施问题有关,或需更聚焦急性临终情境管理及全科/专科安宁疗护参与。
核心结论
- PACE多组分安宁疗护项目对养老院居民临终前1个月医院使用及死亡地点均无统计学显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- PACE整群随机对照试验(ISRCTN14741671)的二次分析,在7个欧盟国家78家养老院开展。
- 通过问卷收集基线前4个月及干预后死亡数据,由最了解情况的护士/护理助理填写。
- 基线收集551/610份问卷,干预后收集984/1178份问卷,涉及37家干预院和36家对照院。
主要发现
- 项目对急诊就诊无显著影响(OR=1.38,P=.32)。
- 项目对住院无显著影响(OR=0.98,P=.93)。
- 项目对住院时长无显著影响(几何均数差=0.85,P=.44)。
- 项目对死亡地点无显著影响(OR=1.08,P=.80)。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科智能体在评估养老院安宁疗护质量时,不宜仅凭此类多组分培训项目预期改善临终医院使用或死亡地点。
- 若关注临终医院使用与死亡地点,需考虑更聚焦急性临终情境管理及全科或专科安宁疗护的紧密参与。
局限性
- 作者指出无效应可能与部分养老院实施问题有关。
- 本文为二次分析,原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: PACE Steps to Success is a 1-year train-the-trainer program aiming to integrate nonspecialist palliative care into nursing homes via staff education and organizational support. In this study, we aimed to explore whether this program resulted in changes in residents' hospital use and place of death. DESIGN: Secondary analysis of the PACE cluster randomized controlled trial (ISRCTN14741671). Data were collected on deaths over the previous 4 months via questionnaires at baseline and postintervention. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: Questionnaires were completed by the nurse/care-assistant most involved from 78 nursing homes in 7 European Union countries. MEASURES: We measured number of emergency department visits, hospital admissions, length of hospital stay, and place of death. Baseline and postintervention scores between intervention and control groups were compared, and we conducted exploratory mixed-model analyses. We collected 551 out of 610 questionnaires at baseline and 984 out of 1178 at postintervention in 37 intervention and 36 control homes. RESULTS: We found no statistical significant effects of the program on emergency department visits [odds ratio (OR) = 1.38, P = .32], hospital admissions (OR = 0.98, P = .93), length of hospital stay (geometric mean difference = 0.85, P = .44), or place of death (OR = 1.08, P = .80). CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: We found no effect of the PACE program on either hospital use in the last month of life or place of death. Although this may be related to implementation problems in some homes, the program might also require a more specific focus on managing acute end-of-life situations and a closer involvement of general practitioners or specialist palliative care services to influence hospital use or place of death.
引用
- Honinx E, Smets T, Piers R, et al. Lack of Effect of a Multicomponent Palliative Care Program for Nursing Home Residents on Hospital Use in the Last Month of Life and on Place of Death: A Secondary Analysis of a Multicountry Cluster Randomized Control Trial. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2020. PMID: 32646823. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2020.05.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。