长期护理机构中的医院老年人生活计划(HELP-LTC):整群随机对照试验
本研究在514床城市学术型养老院纳入219例发生急性疾病或病情变化的长期护理居民,按单元整群随机分为HELP-LTC组(n=105)与常规照护组(n=114)。HELP-LTC针对认知障碍、不动、脱水及营养不良等谵妄危险因素,由两名认证护理助理每周7天每日两次实施,并向主要提供者提出减少谵妄相关药物的建议。调整基线认知功能后,两组谵妄及谵妄严重度无显著差异,住院率亦无显著差异。
要点
- HELP-LTC未能在长期护理居民中预防谵妄或减轻谵妄症状。
- 两组基线认知功能存在差异,常规照护组优于干预组(CPS=1.33 vs 2.25;P=.004)。
- 总样本33.8%发生新发谵妄,谵妄症状随病程下降(平均CAM-S起始3.63 vs 结束3.27)。
核心结论
- 针对长期护理居民谵妄危险的HELP-LTC干预未能预防谵妄或减轻谵妄症状。
研究设计与样本
- 整群随机对照试验,在514床城市学术型养老院纳入219例发生急性疾病或病情变化的长期护理居民,按单元随机分为HELP-LTC组(n=105)与常规照护组(n=114)。
主要发现
- 参与者平均年龄81.7岁,女性占65.3%。
- 基线时常规照护组认知功能优于干预组(CPS=1.33 vs 2.25;P=.004)。
- 谵妄症状随病程下降(平均CAM-S起始3.63 vs 结束3.27)。
- 总样本33.8%发生新发谵妄。
- 调整基线认知功能后,两组谵妄及谵妄严重度无显著差异,住院率亦无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- HELP-LTC所包含的多组分干预及减少谵妄相关药物的建议,在本研究中未显示可降低长期护理居民的谵妄发生或严重度。
局限性
- 两组基线认知功能存在差异,可能使结果偏向无效。
- 两组均出现超出预期的改善,且两组均接受了质量提升实践(如固定人员分配),可能使结果偏向无效。
- 干预措施经过调整,可能影响效果评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES: The Hospital Elder Life Program (HELP) has been shown to prevent delirium in hospitalized older adults. The objective of this study was to test the efficacy of HELP adapted to long-term care (HELP-LTC). DESIGN: Cluster randomized controlled trial. SETTING: A 514-bed academic urban nursing home. PARTICIPANTS: A total of 219 long-term nursing home residents who developed an acute illness or change in condition were randomly assigned to HELP-LTC (n = 105) or usual care (n = 114) by unit. INTERVENTION: HELP-LTC is a multicomponent intervention targeting delirium risk factors of cognitive impairment, immobility, dehydration, and malnutrition. Two certified nursing assistants (CNAs) delivered HELP-LTC components twice daily 7 days per week. In addition, recommendations were given to primary providers to reduce medications associated with delirium. MEASUREMENTS: Delirium (primary outcome) and delirium severity were ascertained each weekday by a research assistant blinded to group assignment, using the Confusion Assessment Method (CAM) and CAM severity score (CAM-S), respectively. Cognitive function was determined using the Cognitive Performance Scale (CPS). Hospitalization was ascertained by chart review. RESULTS: Participants were 81.7 years of age on average and 65.3% female. At baseline, usual care group participants had better cognitive function than intervention group participants (CPS = 1.33 vs 2.25; P = .004). Delirium symptoms declined over the course of the episode (mean CAM-S = 3.63 at start vs 3.27 at end). Overall, 33.8% of the total sample experienced incident delirium. After adjusting for baseline cognitive function, no significant differences were found in delirium or delirium severity between intervention and usual care groups. Hospitalization was not significantly different between groups. CONCLUSION: An intervention targeting delirium risk in long-term nursing home residents did not prevent delirium or reduce delirium symptoms. Baseline differences in cognitive function between groups, greater than expected improvements in both groups, quality-enhancing practices such as consistent assignments delivered to both groups, and adaptations of the intervention may have biased results toward null. J Am Geriatr Soc 68:2329-2335, 2020.
引用
- Boockvar KS, Judon KM, Eimicke JP, et al. Hospital Elder Life Program in Long-Term Care (HELP-LTC): A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2020. PMID: 32710658. doi:10.1111/jgs.16695
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。