公众是否准备好担任替代决策者?准备度差距与高中课程支持度的全国调查
2019年1月加拿大全国代表性在线调查(n=1000)显示,53.1%受访者自感准备好担任替代决策者(SDM),但仅55.6%与亲人进行过关于价值观和意愿的有意义对话,仅61.7%理解SDM角色。61.1%支持在高中开设相关课程。感知准备度与实际准备度之间存在差距。
要点
- 53.1%自感准备好担任SDM,但仅61.7%理解该角色。
- 仅55.6%与亲人有过关于价值观和意愿的有意义对话。
- 61.1%支持高中课程,仅10.6%反对。
核心结论
- 公众自感准备度与实际准备度之间存在差距,许多人自认了解亲人价值观却未询问其患病或临终意愿。
- 多数受访者支持通过高中教育提升担任SDM的准备度。
研究设计与样本
- 2019年1月加拿大全国代表性样本在线调查,共1000名参与者。
- 主要结局为自报担任SDM的准备度,次要结局为对高中SDM角色课程的支持度,采用多变量分析评估相关因素。
主要发现
- 1000名参与者中53.1%自感准备好担任SDM,75.4%表示理解亲人价值观。
- 仅55.6%报告与亲人就价值观和意愿进行过有意义对话,仅61.7%报告理解SDM角色。
- 自身参与预立医疗照护计划的比例低(23.1%)。
- 多变量分析中,年龄、经验、培训及沟通舒适度与准备度相关。
- 61.1%支持高中课程,28.3%中立,10.6%反对。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科应评估患者及家属对SDM角色的理解与实际沟通情况,识别感知准备度与实际行动之间的差距。
- 可鼓励患者与亲人尽早进行关于价值观和临终意愿的有意义对话,并推动预立医疗照护计划。
- 支持在高中阶段开展SDM角色教育,以提升公众长期准备度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Substitute decision-makers (SDMs) make decisions on behalf of patients who do not have capacity, in line with previously expressed wishes, values and beliefs. However, miscommunications and poor awareness of previous wishes often lead to inappropriate care. Increasing public preparedness to communicate on behalf of loved ones may improve care in patients requiring an SDM. METHODS: We conducted an online survey in January 2019 with a representative sample of the Canadian population. The primary outcome was self-reported preparedness to be an SDM. The secondary outcome was support for a high school curriculum on the role of SDMs. The effect of socio-demographics, known enablers and barriers to acting as an SDM, and attitudes towards a high school curriculum were assessed using multivariate analysis. RESULTS: Of 1,000 participants, 53.1% felt prepared to be an SDM, and 75.4% stated they understood their loved one's values. However, only 55.6% reported having had a meaningful conversation with their loved one about values and wishes, and only 61.7% reported understanding the SDM role. Engagement in advance care planning for oneself was low (23.1%). Age, experience, training and comfort with communication were associated with preparedness in our multivariate analysis. A high school curriculum was supported by 61.1% of respondents, with 28.3% neutral and 10.6% against it. INTERPRETATION: There is a gap between perceived and actual preparedness to be an SDM. Many report understanding their loved one's values yet have not asked them about wishes in illness or end of life. The majority of respondents support high school education to improve preparedness.
引用
- Wong MKY, Jiang M, Medor MC, et al. Does the public feel prepared to be substitute decision-makers? Gaps in preparedness and support for a high school curriculum: a national survey. Age Ageing. 2021. PMID: 32459301. doi:10.1093/ageing/afaa100
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。