衰弱指数预测性能随临床域可用性的变化
基于美国国家健康与老龄化趋势研究约6206名社区老年人,构建41变量衰弱指数(FI),评估删除单个或多个临床域后对5年死亡、1年失能和跌倒风险的判别能力。删除任一单域对C统计量影响较小,但删除三或四个域后判别能力下降。
要点
- 删除任一单域仅轻微改变C统计量,但会改变FI分布和衰弱患病率。
核心结论
- FI的判别能力对任一单个域缺失稳健,但风险预测受多个域缺失影响。
研究设计与样本
- 基于美国国家健康与老龄化趋势研究的分析,纳入约6206名社区老年人,构建41变量衰弱指数(FI),比较删除单个和多个域后的C统计量。
主要发现
- 在robust参与者中,缺失ADL的模型最常误分类(19%被误分为pre-frail);在pre-frail和frail参与者中,缺失合并症的模型最常误分类(69.2%从pre-frail误分为robust,24%从frail误分为pre-frail,4.9%从frail误分为robust)。
临床怎么用
- 临床或研究中使用FI时,单个域缺失对判别能力影响有限,但多个域缺失会削弱风险预测,需注意数据完整性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Determine the effects of missing data in frailty identification and risk prediction. DESIGN: Analysis of the National Health in Aging Trends Study. SETTING: Community. PARTICIPANTS: About 6206 older adults. MEASUREMENTS: A 41-variable frailty index (FI) was constructed with the following domains: comorbidities, activities of daily living (ADLs), instrumental activities of daily living, self-reported physical limitations, physical performance, and neuropsychiatric tests. We evaluated discrimination after removing single and multiple domains, comparing C-statistics for predicting 5-year risk of mortality and 1-year risks of disability and falls. RESULTS: The full FI yielded a mean of .18 and C-statistics of .72 (95% confidence interval, .70-.74) for mortality, .80 (.77-.82) for disability, and .66 (.64-.68) for falls. Removal of any single domain shifted the FI distribution, resulting in a mean FI ranging from .13 (removing comorbidities) to .20 (removing ADLs) and frailty prevalence (FI ≥ .25) from 16.0% to 28.7%. Among robust participants models missing ADLs misclassified most often, (19% as pre-frail). Among pre-frail and frail participants missing comorbidities misclassified most often(69.2% from pre-frail to robust, 24% from frail to pre-frail, and 4.9% from frail to robust). Removal of any single domain minimally changed C-statistics: mortality, .71-.73; disability, .79-.80; and falls, .64-.66. Removing neuropsychiatric testing and physical performance yielded comparable C-statistics of .70, .78, and .66 for mortality, ADLs, and falls, respectively. However, removal of three or four domains based on likely availability decreased C-statistics for mortality (.69, .66),disability (.75, .70), and falls (.64, .63), respectively. CONCLUSION: While FI discrimination is robust to missing information in any single domain, risk prediction is affected by absence of multiple domains. This work informs the application of FI as a clinical and research tool. J Am Geriatr Soc 68:1771-1777, 2020.
引用
- Shi SM, McCarthy EP, Mitchell S, et al. Changes in Predictive Performance of a Frailty Index with Availability of Clinical Domains. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2020. PMID: 32274807. doi:10.1111/jgs.16436
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。