身体衰弱测量及其临床应用的原则与问题
本文讨论衰弱评估工具的开发应以验证过程为基础,即证实测量工具能准确精确地测量其意图测量的构念。作者以身体衰弱表型构念为例阐述内容效度、效标效度和构念效度原则,并指出认知、疾病严重程度和失能等交叉概念的角色、衰弱作为状态还是连续体等未解决的概念问题,以及临床应用中需区分针对症状与生理的干预、改进前衰弱筛查工具、满足可行性需求等考量。
要点
- 衰弱评估工具开发应基于验证过程,证实其能准确精确测量意图构念。
- 验证关键要素包括内容效度、效标效度和构念效度,尤以构念效度为重点。
- 未解决概念问题包括认知、疾病严重程度和失能等交叉概念在衰弱测量中的角色。
核心结论
- 衰弱评估的发展应以验证过程为基础,即证实测量工具能准确精确地测量其意图测量的构念。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为方法学论述,阐述衰弱测量验证原则并以身体衰弱表型构念为例进行说明。
主要发现
- 验证关键要素为内容效度、效标效度和构念效度,并强调构念效度。
- 未解决的概念问题包括认知、疾病严重程度和失能等交叉概念在衰弱测量中的角色。
- 未解决的概念问题包括衰弱应概念化为状态还是连续体。
- 未解决的概念问题包括进一步理解衰弱是否可能需要动态测量和系统概念。
关键数值与推荐
- 构念必须被清晰定义,然后进行分析以证实测量能准确精确地测量其意图测量的内容。
临床怎么用
- 临床需区分针对衰弱「症状」的干预与针对 underlying physiology 的干预。
- 需改进用于在衰弱进展早期筛查个体的「前衰弱」测量工具。
- 需应对可行性需求,并进一步愿景规划后开展严格疗效研究以覆盖衰弱评估在临床实践中的潜在用途。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: "Frailty" has attracted attention for its promise of identifying vulnerable older adults, hence its potential use to better tailor geriatric health care. There remains substantial controversy, however, regarding its nature and ascertainment. Recent years have seen a proliferation of frailty assessment methods. We argue that the development of frailty assessments should be grounded in "validation"-the process of substantiating that a measurement accurately and precisely measures what it intends, identify unresolved measurement issues, and highlight measurement-related considerations for clinical practice. METHODS: Principles for validating frailty measures are elucidated. We follow principles-articulated, for example, by Borsboom-in which a construct must be clearly defined and then analyses undertaken to substantiate that a measurement accurately and precisely measures what it intends. Key elements are content validity, criterion validity, and construct validity, with an emphasis on the latter. RESULTS: We illustrate the principles for a physical frailty phenotype construct. CONCLUSIONS: Unresolved conceptual issues include the roles of intersecting concepts such as cognition, disease severity, and disability in frailty measurement, conceptualization of frailty as a state versus a continuum, and the potential need for dynamic measures and systems concepts in furthering understanding of frailty. Clinical considerations include needs to distinguish interventions designed to address frailty "symptoms" versus underlying physiology, improve "prefrailty" measures intended to screen individuals early in their frailty progression, address feasibility demands, and further visioning followed by rigorous efficacy research to address the landscape of potential uses of frailty assessment in clinical practice.
引用
- Bandeen-Roche K, Gross AL, Varadhan R, et al. Principles and Issues for Physical Frailty Measurement and Its Clinical Application. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2020. PMID: 31287490. doi:10.1093/gerona/glz158
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。