围手术期老年综合评估:下一步走向何方
本文讨论老年综合评估(CGA)在围手术期用于改善老年手术患者结局的现状。传统CGA由老年科医生领导的多学科团队提供,但鉴于老年医学人力挑战,有建议非老年科医生也可实施CGA。HOW-CGA开发了工具包以促进非老年科医生在围手术期实施CGA,但在两家医院站点,工具包的采纳和实施受限于面效度可能不足、行为和文化障碍,以及认为老年医学专业知识对CGA和优化至关重要。与此一致,英国观察到老年科医生领导的老年手术患者CGA服务有所扩展。为证明围手术期CGA服务的有效性,应将实施科学与卫生服务研究方法相结合,并通过关联的国家审计利用大数据。
要点
- 传统围手术期CGA由老年科医生领导的多学科团队提供。
- 非老年科医生实施CGA的工具包在两家医院采纳和实施受限。
- 英国老年科医生领导的围手术期CGA服务有所扩展。
核心结论
- 围手术期CGA服务宜由老年科医生领导,非老年科医生实施工具包面临障碍。
- 证明围手术期CGA服务有效性需结合实施科学、卫生服务研究方法和大数据。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述/评论,基于HOW-CGA工具包在两家医院站点的实施经验及英国服务扩展观察。
主要发现
- HOW-CGA工具包在两家医院站点的采纳和实施受限。
- 限制因素包括面效度可能不足、行为和文化障碍,以及认为老年医学专业知识是关键。
- 英国观察到老年科医生领导的老年手术患者CGA服务有所扩展。
临床怎么用
- 围手术期CGA应由老年科医生领导的多学科团队实施。
- 推广非老年科医生实施CGA需先解决面效度、行为和文化障碍。
- 评估围手术期CGA服务有效性可结合实施科学、卫生服务研究及关联国家审计大数据。
局限性
- 原文未报告具体研究设计、样本量或定量数据。
- HOW-CGA工具包实施经验仅来自两家医院站点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) is being employed in the perioperative setting to improve outcomes for older surgical patients. Traditionally CGA is delivered by a geriatrician led multidisciplinary team but with the acknowledged workforce challenges in geriatric medicine, it has been suggested that non-geriatricians may be able to deliver CGA. HOW-CGA developed a toolkit to facilitate the delivery of CGA by non-geriatricians in the perioperative setting. Across two hospital sites uptake and implementation of this toolkit was limited by a potential lack of face validity, behavioural and cultural barriers and an acknowledgement that geriatric medicine expertise is key to CGA and optimisation. In-keeping with this finding there has been an observed expansion in geriatrician led CGA services for older surgical patients in the UK. In order to demonstrate the effectiveness of perioperative CGA services, implementation science should be combined with health services research methodology and the use of big data through linked national audit.
引用
- Dhesi J, Moonesinghe SR, Partridge J, et al. Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment in the perioperative setting; where next? Age Ageing. 2019. PMID: 31147709. doi:10.1093/ageing/afz069
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。