低摄入性脱水体征在养老院老人中诊断准确性差
该前瞻性诊断准确性研究纳入英国56家养老院188名≥65岁居民,评估49种脱水体征与症状对低摄入性脱水的诊断价值。以血清渗透压>300 mOsm/kg为现患脱水、≥295 mOsm/kg为即将脱水标准,发现常用体征均无法有效区分脱水与否。结论建议弃用这些体征,改用两阶段筛查:先计算血清渗透压,高风险者再测血清渗透压。
要点
- 常用脱水体征在养老院老人中诊断准确性不足,无法识别脱水者。
- 建议弃用传统体征,改用计算血清渗透压的两阶段筛查流程。
- 现患脱水占20%,即将脱水占28%,但体征均无鉴别力。
核心结论
- 常用低摄入性脱水体征在养老院老人中缺乏基本诊断准确性,无法有效识别脱水者。
- 建议将传统体征撤出临床实践,替换为基于计算血清渗透压的两阶段筛查流程。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性诊断准确性研究,纳入英国诺福克和萨福克56家养老院的188名≥65岁居民。
- 参与者排除心脏或肾功能衰竭及接受安宁疗护者;66%为女性,平均年龄85.7岁(标准差7.8),MMSE中位数23(四分位距18-26)。
- 对49种体征和症状进行双盲评估,并以血清渗透压作为参考标准。
主要发现
- 20%的居民存在现患低摄入性脱水,另有28%存在即将脱水。
- 在现患脱水(>300 mOsm/kg)和即将脱水(≥295 mOsm/kg)两个切点下,常用临床体征和症状均不能有效区分有无低摄入性脱水。
关键数值与推荐
- 现患脱水定义为血清渗透压>300 mOsm/kg,即将脱水定义为≥295 mOsm/kg。
- 二分类检验目标为敏感度和特异度均>70%,连续检验目标为ROC曲线下面积>0.7。
- 建议两阶段筛查:先以Khajuria和Krahn公式由钠、钾、尿素和葡萄糖计算血清渗透压,计算值>295 mmol/L者再测血清渗透压。
临床怎么用
- 不应依赖皮肤弹性、黏膜干燥、毛细血管再充盈等常用体征判断养老院老人是否脱水。
- 可采用两阶段筛查:常规计算血清渗透压,高风险者(计算值>295 mmol/L)再行血清渗透压测定。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the diagnostic accuracy of commonly used signs and symptoms of low-intake dehydration in older care home residents. DESIGN: Prospective diagnostic accuracy study. SETTING: 56 care homes offering residential, nursing, and/or dementia care to older adults in Norfolk and Suffolk, United Kingdom. PARTICIPANTS: 188 consecutively recruited care home residents aged ≥65 years, without cardiac or renal failure and not receiving palliative care. Overall, 66% were female, the mean age was 85.7 years (standard deviation 7.8), and the median Mini-Mental State Examination MMSE score was 23 (interquartile range 18-26). INDEX TESTS: Over 2 hours, participants underwent double-blind assessment of 49 signs and symptoms of dehydration and measurement of serum osmolality from a venous blood sample. Signs and symptoms included skin turgor; mouth, skin, and axillary dryness; capillary refill; sunken eyes; blood pressure on resting and after standing; body temperature; pulse rate; and self-reported feelings of thirst and well-being. REFERENCE STANDARD: Serum osmolality, with current dehydration defined as >300 mOsm/kg, and impending dehydration ≥295 mOsm/kg. OUTCOME MEASURES: For dichotomous tests, we aimed for sensitivity and specificity >70%, and for continuous tests, an area under the curve in receiver operating characteristic plots of >0.7. RESULTS: Although 20% of residents had current low-intake dehydration and a further 28% impending dehydration, none of the commonly used clinical signs and symptoms usefully discriminated between participants with or without low-intake dehydration at either cut-off. CONCLUSIONS/IMPLICATIONS: This study consolidates evidence that commonly used signs and symptoms of dehydration lack even basic levels of diagnostic accuracy in older adults, implying that many who are dehydrated are not being identified, thus compromising their health and well-being. We suggest that these tests be withdrawn from practice and replaced with a 2-stage screening process that includes serum osmolarity, calculated from sodium, potassium, urea, and glucose levels (assessed routinely using the Khajuria and Krahn equation), followed by serum osmolality measurement for those identified as high risk (calculated serum osmolarity >295 mmol/L).
引用
- Bunn DK, Hooper L. Signs and Symptoms of Low-Intake Dehydration Do Not Work in Older Care Home Residents-DRIE Diagnostic Accuracy Study. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2019. PMID: 30872081. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2019.01.122
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。