跨专业团队在痴呆合并髋部骨折治疗决策中考虑的因素
该定性研究对参与痴呆患者髋部骨折后管理的跨专业团队进行深度访谈,包括9名骨科医生、3名医院医生、3名老年科医生、5名护士、3名职业治疗师、3名物理治疗师和2名临床伦理学家。受访者讨论的主要主题为疼痛控制、功能状态和医疗共病;所有老年科医生均提及痴呆及其对康复潜力的影响。结论提示老年科医生参与决策团队的重要性。
要点
- 主要决策考虑因素为疼痛控制、功能状态和医疗共病。
- 功能状态相关因素包括基线功能、康复潜力、社会支持和活动能力重要性。
- 所有老年科医生均提及痴呆及其对康复潜力的影响。
核心结论
- 尽管衰弱、预后和预期寿命在回答中基本缺失,但老年科医生对痴呆、预立医嘱和涉及家属或照护者的强调提示将老年科医生纳入决策团队的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 对参与痴呆患者髋部骨折后管理的跨专业团队进行深度精英访谈的定性分析。
- 访谈对象包括9名骨科医生、3名医院医生、3名老年科医生、5名护士、3名职业治疗师、3名物理治疗师和2名临床伦理学家。
- 访谈逐字转录稿使用QSR International的NVivo 10定性数据库管理软件进行分析和编码。
主要发现
- 大多数受访者讨论的三个主要主题是疼痛控制、功能状态和医疗共病。
- 受访者提及许多与恢复功能状态相关的因素,包括基线功能状态、康复潜力、社会支持和活动能力的重要性。
- 所有老年科医生均提及痴呆及其对康复潜力的影响。
临床怎么用
- 在痴呆合并髋部骨折患者的治疗决策中,应重视疼痛控制、功能状态和医疗共病。
- 决策团队应考虑纳入老年科医生,以关注痴呆、预立医嘱及家属或照护者的参与。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Patients with dementia are at high risk for hip fractures and often have poor outcomes when a fracture is sustained. Despite this poor prognosis, little data are available on what factors should be prioritized to guide surgical decision making in these cases. We aimed to understand the decision-making process for older dementia patients hospitalized after hip fractures. DESIGN: We performed a qualitative analysis of in-depth elite interviews conducted with a clinical care team involved in management of patients with dementia after hospitalization for hip fractures. SETTING: Interviews were conducted with an interprofessional team involved in the care of patients with dementia after being hospitalized for hip fractures. PARTICIPANTS: Interviewees included nine orthopaedic surgeons, three hospitalists, three geriatricians, five nurses, three occupational therapists, three physical therapists, and two clinical ethicists. MEASUREMENTS: Verbatim transcripts of the interviews were analyzed and coded using QSR International's NVivo 10 qualitative database management software. RESULTS: The three main themes that most interviewees discussed were pain control, functional status, and medical comorbidities. Interviewees brought up many factors related to restoring functional status including baseline functional status, rehabilitation potential, social support, and the importance of mobility. Dementia and its impact on rehabilitation potential were mentioned by all geriatricians. CONCLUSION: Although frailty, prognosis, and life expectancy were largely absent from the responses, the emphasis on dementia, advanced directives, and involving family or caregivers by the three geriatricians indicates the importance of including geriatricians in the decision-making team for these patients.
引用
- Baker AC, Ambrose CG, Knudson PL, et al. Factors Considered by Interprofessional Team for Treatment Decision in Hip Fracture with Dementia. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2019. PMID: 30830698. doi:10.1111/jgs.15856
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。