无老年科医生参与的综合老年评估能否实施?两项围手术期外科场景中的形成性评价
本研究旨在为缺乏综合老年评估(CGA)临床传统的医院服务设计改善衰弱老年患者照护的方法。干预基于CGA原则,采用质量改进方法学嵌入照护流程,并通过定性方法与共同生产指导干预开发,面向英国两家大型教学医院围手术期/外科肿瘤照护路径的医护人员。形成性定性评价以规范化过程理论指导数据收集与分析,结果显示临床医生同意使用工具包并识别潜在获益,但实施仍处初期,受国家限时目标主导及对患者即时治疗和康复的关切所竞争,部分参与者认为CGA需要老年科医生持续专科投入但其可持续性不明确。
要点
- 临床工具包旨在赋能非老年科团队实施CGA,初期受到欢迎但未完全实现既定目标。
- 实施受国家限时目标竞争、服务开发周期长及专业领域观点分歧影响。
- 部分围手术期路径参与者认为CGA需要老年科医生持续专科投入,可持续性不明确。
核心结论
- 为非老年科团队设计的CGA临床工具包初期受到欢迎,但因需要老年科医生支持的长期服务开发、竞争性优先事项及对适当专业领域的分歧观点,未完全实现既定目标。
研究设计与样本
- 形成性定性评价,干预基于CGA原则并采用质量改进方法学嵌入照护流程,面向英国两家大型教学医院围手术期/外科肿瘤照护路径的医护人员。
- 数据收集与分析由规范化过程理论指导。
主要发现
- 临床医生同意使用工具包,并识别出改善手术决策和术前实施干预等潜在获益。
- 各站点认为术前评估并非CGA的最佳场所,12个月试验结束时实施仍处初期。
- 实施努力与国家限时目标的主导地位以及对患者即时治疗和康复的关切相竞争。
- 部分围手术期路径参与者认为CGA需要老年科医生持续专科投入,但其可持续性不明确。
临床怎么用
- 在缺乏CGA传统的围手术期外科服务中,非老年科团队使用CGA工具包需配套老年科医生支持的长期服务开发。
- 实施CGA需应对国家限时目标等竞争性优先事项,并协调关于专业领域的观点分歧。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: the aim of this study was to design an approach to improving care for frail older patients in hospital services where comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA) was not part of the clinical tradition. METHODS: the intervention was based on the principles of CGA, using quality improvement methodology to embed care processes. Qualitative methods and coproduction were used to inform development of the intervention, which was directed towards the health care professionals involved in peri-operative/surgical cancer care pathways in two large UK teaching hospitals. A formative, qualitative evaluation was undertaken; data collection and analysis were guided by normalisation process theory. RESULTS: the clinicians involved agreed to use the toolkit, identifying potential benefits including improved surgical decision making and delivery of interventions pre-operatively. However, sites concluded that pre-operative assessment was not the best place for CGA, and at the end of the 12-month trial, implementation was still nascent. Efforts competed against the dominance of national time-limited targets, and concerns relating to patients' immediate treatment and recovery. Some participants involved in the peri-operative pathway felt that CGA required ongoing specialist input from geriatricians, but it was not clear that this was sustainable. CONCLUSIONS: clinical toolkits designed to empower non-geriatric teams to deliver CGA were received with initial enthusiasm, but did not fully achieve their stated aims due to the need for an extended period of service development with geriatrician support, competing priorities, and divergent views about appropriate professional domains.
引用
- Kocman D, Regen E, Phelps K, et al. Can comprehensive geriatric assessment be delivered without the need for geriatricians? A formative evaluation in two perioperative surgical settings. Age Ageing. 2019. PMID: 30916758. doi:10.1093/ageing/afz025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。