纵向老年结局研究中死亡竞争风险的敏感性分析
该研究基于Precipitating Events Project前瞻性队列中754名70岁及以上初始无日常生活活动能力残疾的社区居住老年人,通过多重插补处理死亡者缺失结局,并设置不同情景进行敏感性分析,评估暴露与二分类、计数及至事件时间三类结局的关联稳健性。结果显示,当长期随访累积死亡率较高时,死亡竞争风险可引入实质性偏倚;而随访6个月的残疾计数与功能恢复时间结局仅在极不可信的临床情景下失去显著性。
要点
- 长期随访累积死亡率高时,死亡竞争风险可实质偏倚非死亡结局的关联。
- 随访6个月的残疾计数与恢复时间结局在合理情景下关联稳健。
- 对死亡者缺失结局采用多重插补并做情景敏感性分析可评估偏倚。
核心结论
- 死亡竞争风险在长期随访且累积死亡率高时可对非死亡结局的暴露关联引入实质性偏倚。
- 该方法可用于评估非至事件时间结局中死亡竞争风险所致潜在偏倚。
研究设计与样本
- 基于Precipitating Events Project前瞻性队列数据的二次分析,纳入754名70岁及以上初始社区居住且四项基本日常生活活动无残疾者。
- 对死亡者缺失结局在不同情景下进行多重插补,并做敏感性分析评估暴露与二分类、计数及至事件时间三类结局的关联稳健性。
主要发现
- 对于跌倒相关住院这一二分类结局,当死亡者被保留在风险池中且超过10年未发生结局事件时,超重或肥胖的关联失去显著性。
- 对于出院后6个月每月总残疾计数(0-13),以Fried表型衰弱(0-5,不衰弱=0,衰弱前期=1-2,衰弱=3-5)为暴露,随访6个月时仅在高度不可信的临床情景下关联失去显著性。
- 对于住院期间残疾加重者至功能恢复的天数,以视力损害为暴露,随访6个月时仅在高度不可信的临床情景下关联失去显著性。
关键数值与推荐
- 跌倒相关住院结局的暴露为超重或肥胖指标。
- 残疾计数结局的暴露为Fried表型衰弱,评分0-5,不衰弱=0、衰弱前期=1-2、衰弱=3-5。
- 功能恢复时间结局的暴露为视力损害,随访6个月。
临床怎么用
- 在老年纵向研究中分析非死亡结局时,应评估死亡竞争风险,尤其长期随访累积死亡率高时。
- 可采用对死亡者缺失结局多重插补并设置不同情景的敏感性分析,判断关联稳健性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To address the competing risk of death in longitudinal studies of older persons, we demonstrate sensitivity analyses that evaluate robustness of associations between exposures and three outcome types: dichotomous, count, and time to event. DESIGN: A secondary analysis of data from a prospective cohort study. SETTING: Community-based data from the Precipitating Events Project in New Haven, CT. PARTICIPANTS: Persons 70 years and older who were initially community dwelling and without disability in the four basic activities of daily living (N = 754). MEASUREMENTS: Missing outcome values from decedents were multiply imputed under different scenarios. Three outcomes were examined: dichotomous fall-related hospitalization (FRH); a count (0-13) of total disability in each of the 6 months after discharge; and days to functional recovery among those whose disability worsened in the hospital. Each outcome had a different exposure: for dichotomous, indicators of being overweight or obese; for count, frailty from the Fried phenotype (0-5, where not frail = 0, prefrail = 1-2, and frail = 3-5); for days to recovery, vision impairment. RESULTS: For FRH, being overweight or obese lost significance when decedents were kept in the risk pool without outcome events for over 10 years. For disability count and time to recovery, with follow-up of 6 months, exposures only lost significance under highly implausible clinical scenarios. CONCLUSION: This method facilitates evaluation of potential bias from the competing risk of death in longitudinal studies for nondeath outcomes that are not necessarily time to event. Results suggest that death introduces substantive bias when long-term follow-up results in cumulatively high levels of mortality. J Am Geriatr Soc 67:357-362, 2019.
引用
- Murphy TE, Gill TM, Leo-Summers LS, et al. The Competing Risk of Death in Longitudinal Geriatric Outcomes. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2018. PMID: 30537050. doi:10.1111/jgs.15697
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。