在多重慢性病老年人中实施患者优先事项照护的可行性
本研究在美国康涅狄格州1个初级保健和1个心脏科诊所开展实施可行性研究,纳入9名初级保健医生、5名心脏科医生和119名多重慢性病老年人,采用实践变革框架和PDSA循环实施患者优先事项照护(PPC)。10个月后119名老年人入组并明确优先事项,92名(77%)返回初级保健医生处,其中56次(46%)就诊记录有优先事项讨论;工作流程挑战已识别并解决,但临床医生时间和决策仍具挑战。将基于疾病的决策转变为与优先事项一致的决策看似困难但可行。
要点
- PPC在初级保健和心脏科实践中可行实施,77%入组老年人返回初级保健医生处。
- 46%的返回就诊中临床医生记录了患者优先事项讨论。
- 临床医生时间和决策(如指南、指标、不现实优先事项担忧)仍是挑战。
核心结论
- 将基于疾病的决策转变为与优先事项一致的决策看似困难但在临床环境中可行实施。
研究设计与样本
- 在康涅狄格州1个初级保健和1个心脏科诊所开展的实施可行性研究,纳入9名初级保健医生、5名心脏科医生和119名多重慢性病老年人。
- 采用基于实践变革框架的方法和持续的计划-执行-研究-处理(PDSA)循环实施PPC。
主要发现
- 10个月后119名老年人入组并明确优先事项,92名(77%)返回初级保健医生处。
- 56次(46%)返回就诊中临床医生记录了患者优先事项讨论。
- 已识别并解决的工作流程挑战包括患者入组滞后、电子健康记录中优先事项讨论记录和跨专业沟通。
临床怎么用
- PPC核心要素包括领导支持、临床冠军、优先事项协调员、培训、电子健康记录支持、工作流程开发和持续修改以及协作学习。
- 针对工作流程和临床决策挑战,正在开展PDSA循环并与国家专家和同行持续协作学习。
局限性
- 临床医生提供PPC的时间仍是挑战。
- 决策挑战包括临床医生认为已在执行PPC、对指南、指标和不现实优先事项的担忧,以及初级保健医生与患者之间和初级保健医生与心脏科医生之间治疗决策的差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Older adults with multiple chronic conditions (MCCs) receive care that is fragmented and burdensome, lacks evidence, and most importantly is not focused on what matters most to them. An implementation feasibility study of Patient Priorities Care (PPC), a new approach to care that is based on health outcome goals and healthcare preferences, was conducted. This study took place at 1 primary care and 1 cardiology practice in Connecticut and involved 9 primary care providers (PCPs), 5 cardiologists, and 119 older adults with MCCs. PPC was implemented using methods based on a practice change framework and continuous plan-do-study-act (PDSA) cycles. Core elements included leadership support, clinical champions, priorities facilitators, training, electronic health record (EHR) support, workflow development and continuous modification, and collaborative learning. PPC processes for clinic workflow and decision-making were developed, and clinicians were trained. After 10 months, 119 older adults enrolled and had priorities identified; 92 (77%) returned to their PCP after priorities identification. In 56 (46%) of these visits, clinicians documented patient priorities discussions. Workflow challenges identified and solved included patient enrollment lags, EHR documentation of priorities discussions, and interprofessional communication. Time for clinicians to provide PPC remains a challenge, as does decision-making, including clinicians' perceptions that they are already doing so; clinicians' concerns about guidelines, metrics, and unrealistic priorities; and differences between PCPs and patients and between PCPs and cardiologists about treatment decisions. PDSA cycles and continuing collaborative learning with national experts and peers are taking place to address workflow and clinical decision-making challenges. Translating disease-based to priorities-aligned decision-making appears challenging but feasible to implement in a clinical setting.
引用
- Blaum CS, Rosen J, Naik AD, et al. Feasibility of Implementing Patient Priorities Care for Older Adults with Multiple Chronic Conditions. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2018. PMID: 30281777. doi:10.1111/jgs.15465
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。