衰弱表型与缺陷累积衰弱指数对主动脉瓣置换术后恢复的预测比较
研究前瞻性评估91例SAVR和137例TAVR患者的衰弱表型与缺陷累积衰弱指数(FI),比较两者预测术后6个月死亡或恢复不良的能力。FI的C统计量高于衰弱表型(0.74 vs 0.63,p=.01),且加入传统手术风险模型可改善预测(NRI 26.4%,p=.02),而衰弱表型无显著增益。FI在TAVR患者中增益明显(NRI 42.8%,p<.01),在SAVR患者中不显著。
要点
- TAVR患者衰弱表型患病率(85% vs 38%)和平均FI(0.37 vs 0.24)均高于SAVR患者。
- FI预测死亡或恢复不良的C统计量高于衰弱表型(0.74 vs 0.63,p=.01)。
- FI加入传统模型改善预测(NRI 26.4%,p=.02),衰弱表型无显著增益。
核心结论
- 缺陷累积衰弱指数(FI)对SAVR和TAVR患者术后6个月死亡或恢复不良的预测优于衰弱表型。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,纳入学术医疗中心接受SAVR(n=91)或TAVR(n=137)的患者,评估衰弱表型和FI。
- 结局为术后6个月死亡或恢复不良,定义为22项日常活动能力下降且NYHA心功能III或IV级。
- 采用C统计量、净重分类改善(NRI)和综合判别改善评价预测能力及对传统手术风险模型的增量价值。
主要发现
- TAVR患者衰弱表型患病率高于SAVR患者(85% vs 38%,p<.001),平均FI也更高(0.37 vs 0.24,p<.001)。
- 总体队列中,FI预测死亡或恢复不良的C统计量高于衰弱表型(0.74 vs 0.63,p=.01)。
- FI加入传统模型改善预测(NRI 26.4%,p=.02;综合判别改善7.7%,p<.001),衰弱表型无显著增益(NRI 4.0%,p=.70;综合判别改善1.6%,p=.08)。
- FI的增量价值在TAVR患者中显著(NRI 42.8%,p<.01),在SAVR患者中不显著(NRI 25.0%,p=.29)。
- 衰弱表型在TAVR(NRI 6.8%,p=.26)或SAVR患者(NRI 25.0%,p=.29)中均无显著增量。
关键数值与推荐
- FI预测死亡或恢复不良的C统计量为0.74,衰弱表型为0.63(p=.01)。
- FI加入传统模型的NRI为26.4%(p=.02),综合判别改善为7.7%(p<.001)。
- TAVR患者中FI的NRI为42.8%(p<.01)。
临床怎么用
- 对接受SAVR或TAVR的老年患者,可优先使用缺陷累积衰弱指数(FI)而非衰弱表型来评估术后死亡或恢复不良风险。
- FI可加入传统手术风险模型以改善风险分层,尤其在TAVR患者中增量价值更明显。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Frailty phenotype and deficit-accumulation frailty index (FI) are widely used measures of frailty. Their performance in predicting recovery after surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) and transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) has not been compared. METHODS: Patients undergoing SAVR (n = 91) or TAVR (n = 137) at an academic medical center were prospectively assessed for frailty phenotype and FI. Outcomes were death or poor recovery, defined as a decline in ability to perform 22 daily activities and New York Heart Association class 3 or 4 at 6 months after surgery. The predictive ability of frailty phenotype versus FI and their additive value to a traditional surgical risk model were evaluated using C-statistics, net reclassification improvement (NRI), and integrated discrimination improvement. RESULTS: TAVR patients had higher prevalence of phenotypic frailty (85% vs 38%, p < .001) and greater mean FI (0.37 vs 0.24, p < .001) than SAVR patients. In the overall cohort, FI had a higher C-statistic than frailty phenotype (0.74 vs 0.63, p = .01) for predicting death or poor recovery. Adding FI to the traditional model improved prediction (NRI, 26.4%, p = .02; integrated discrimination improvement, 7.7%, p < .001), while adding phenotypic frailty did not (NRI, 4.0%, p = .70; integrated discrimination improvement, 1.6%, p = .08). The additive value of FI was evident in TAVR patients (NRI, 42.8%, p < .01) but not in SAVR patients (NRI, 25.0%, p = .29). Phenotypic frailty did not add significantly in either TAVR (NRI, 6.8%, p = .26) or SAVR patients (NRI, 25.0%, p = .29). CONCLUSIONS: Deficit-accumulation FI provides better prediction of death or poor recovery than frailty phenotype in older patients undergoing SAVR and TAVR.
引用
- Shi S, Afilalo J, Lipsitz LA, et al. Frailty Phenotype and Deficit Accumulation Frailty Index in Predicting Recovery After Transcatheter and Surgical Aortic Valve Replacement. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2019. PMID: 30165422. doi:10.1093/gerona/gly196
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。