轻度与重度痴呆老年人初级姑息照护质量:基于质量指标的国际死亡率回溯研究
该研究通过比利时、意大利和西班牙的全科医生哨点网络进行死亡率回溯调查,使用九项质量指标评估874例65岁及以上非突然死亡、经全科医生判断为轻度或重度痴呆患者的初级姑息照护质量。结果显示三国在整体质量上差异显著,尤其在规律疼痛测量、对临近死亡的接受度、医患沟通及专科姑息服务参与方面,但在疼痛测量和避免可避免住院方面存在共同改进空间。
要点
- 三国在规律疼痛测量、医患沟通和专科姑息服务参与等质量指标上得分差异显著。
- 疼痛测量和预防可避免住院是三国共同的主要改进领域。
- 亲属与全科医生沟通、院外死亡及丧亲辅导得分国家间无差异。
核心结论
- 三国初级姑息照护整体质量差异显著,但在疼痛测量和预防可避免住院方面存在相似改进空间。
研究设计与样本
- 通过比利时、意大利和西班牙全国及地区代表性全科医生哨点网络开展死亡率回溯调查,纳入874例65岁及以上非突然死亡、经全科医生判断为轻度或重度痴呆的患者。
- 应用通过文献回顾和专家共识制定的九项质量指标进行评估。
主要发现
- 规律疼痛测量得分:轻度痴呆比利时44%、意大利12%、西班牙50%;重度痴呆比利时41%、意大利9%、西班牙47%。
- 对临近死亡的接受度得分:轻度痴呆比利时59%、意大利48%、西班牙33%;重度痴呆比利时41%、意大利21%、西班牙20%。
- 医患关于疾病的沟通得分(轻度痴呆):比利时42%、意大利6%、西班牙20%。
- 专科姑息服务参与得分(轻度痴呆):比利时60%、意大利20%、西班牙77%。
- 医患关于医疗治疗的沟通得分(轻度痴呆):比利时34%、意大利12%、西班牙4%;重复多学科会诊得分:轻度痴呆比利时39%、意大利5%、西班牙8%,重度痴呆比利时36%、意大利10%、西班牙8%。
关键数值与推荐
- 应用九项质量指标评估初级姑息照护质量。
- 亲属与全科医生沟通、院外死亡及丧亲辅导得分国家间无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科智能体医生应关注痴呆患者初级姑息照护中疼痛测量和避免可避免住院的改进空间。
- 参考各国质量指标得分差异,优化医患沟通、专科姑息服务参与及多学科会诊流程。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: measuring the quality of primary palliative care for older people with dementia in different countries is important to identify areas where improvements can be made. OBJECTIVE: using quality indicators (QIs), we systematically investigated the overall quality of primary palliative care for older people with dementia in three different countries. DESIGN/SETTING: a mortality follow-back survey through nation- and region-wide representative Sentinel Networks of General Practitioners (GPs) in Belgium, Italy and Spain. GPs registered all patient deaths in their practice. We applied a set of nine QIs developed through literature review and expert consensus. SUBJECTS: patients aged 65 or older, who died non-suddenly with mild or severe dementia as judged by GPs (n = 874). RESULTS: findings showed significantly different QI scores between Belgium and Italy for regular pain measurement (mild dementia: BE = 44%, IT = 12%, SP = 50% | severe dementia: BE = 41%, IT = 9%, SP = 47%), acceptance of approaching death (mild: BE = 59%, IT = 48%, SP = 33% | severe: BE = 41%, IT = 21%, SP = 20%), patient-GP communication about illness (mild: BE = 42%, IT = 6%, SP = 20%) and involvement of specialised palliative services (mild: BE = 60%, IT = 20%, SP = 77%). The scores in Belgium differed from Italy and Spain for patient-GP communication about medical treatments (mild: BE = 34%, IT = 12%, SP = 4%) and repeated multidisciplinary consultations (mild: BE = 39%, IT = 5%, SP = 8% | severe: BE = 36%, IT = 10%, SP = 8%). The scores for relative-GP communication, patient death outside hospitals and bereavement counselling did not differ between countries. CONCLUSION: while the countries studied differed considerably in the overall quality of primary palliative care, they have similarities in room for improvement, in particular, pain measurement and prevention of avoidable hospitalisations.
引用
- Miranda R, Penders YWH, Smets T, et al. Quality of primary palliative care for older people with mild and severe dementia: an international mortality follow-back study using quality indicators. Age Ageing. 2018. PMID: 29893776. doi:10.1093/ageing/afy087
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。