以照护者为中心的谵妄检测工具验证:系统综述
该系统综述检索了MEDLINE、EMBASE、PsycINFO、CINAHL和Scopus(至2017年5月15日),纳入6项研究、6种以照护者为中心的谵妄检测工具。照护者自评工具(FAM-CAM、Sour Seven)的心理测量学特性优于照护者知情工具(SQiD、SSQ-Delirium)。结论认为这些工具有望改善谵妄检测,但需更大样本、多中心的比较研究确定信效度。
要点
- 照护者自评工具FAM-CAM敏感度75%、特异度91%;Sour Seven阳性预测值89.5%、阴性预测值90%。
- 照护者知情工具SQiD敏感度80%、特异度71%;SSQ-Delirium敏感度79.6%、特异度56.1%。
- 所有工具设计为几分钟内完成,条目数≤11项。
核心结论
- 以照护者为中心的谵妄检测工具在改善谵妄检测及相关患者和照护者结局方面显示出前景。
- 需更大样本、多中心的比较研究来确定这些工具的信效度特征。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、PsycINFO、CINAHL和Scopus从建库至2017年5月15日。
- 纳入报告以照护者为中心谵妄检测工具效度或相关患者/照护者结局的队列或横断面设计研究。
- 共审查6056条标题和摘要,最终纳入6篇文章,识别6种工具。
主要发现
- 6种工具均设计为几分钟内完成,条目数≤11项。
- 3种为照护者自评工具:FAM-CAM、I-AGeD、Sour Seven;3种为照护者知情工具:SQiD、SSQ-Delirium、Stressful Caregiving Response to Experiences of Dying。
- FAM-CAM敏感度75%(95%CI=35-95%)、特异度91%(95%CI=74-97%);Sour Seven阳性预测值89.5%、阴性预测值90%。
- SQiD敏感度80%(95%CI=28.4-99.5%)、特异度71%(95%CI=41.9-91.6%);SSQ-Delirium敏感度79.6%、特异度56.1%。
- 照护者自评工具的心理测量学特性优于照护者知情工具。
关键数值与推荐
- FAM-CAM:敏感度75%(95%CI=35-95%),特异度91%(95%CI=74-97%)。
- Sour Seven:阳性预测值89.5%,阴性预测值90%。
- SQiD:敏感度80%(95%CI=28.4-99.5%),特异度71%(95%CI=41.9-91.6%)。
- SSQ-Delirium:敏感度79.6%,特异度56.1%。
临床怎么用
- 在住院成人谵妄检测中可考虑使用以照护者为中心的工具,照护者自评工具可能心理测量学特性更优。
- 选用工具时需注意现有验证研究样本量有限,应结合临床情境谨慎解读结果。
局限性
- 仅纳入6篇文章,样本量有限。
- 需要更大样本量和多中心的比较研究来确定信效度特征。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To summarize the validity of caregiver-centered delirium detection tools in hospitalized adults and assess associated patient and caregiver outcomes. DESIGN: Systematic review. SETTING: We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL, and Scopus from inception to May 15, 2017. PARTICIPANTS: Hospitalized adults. INTERVENTION: Caregiver-centered delirium detection tools. MEASUREMENTS: We drafted a protocol from the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Two reviewers independently completed abstract and full-text review, data extraction, and quality assessment. We summarized findings using descriptive statistics including mean, median, standard deviation, range, frequencies (percentages), and Cohen's kappa. Studies that reported on the validity of caregiver-centered delirium detection tools or associated patient and caregiver outcomes and were cohort or cross-sectional in design were included. RESULTS: We reviewed 6,056 titles and abstracts, included 6 articles, and identified 6 caregiver-centered tools. All tools were designed to be administered in several minutes or less and had 11 items or fewer. Three tools were caregiver administered (completed independently by caregivers): Family Confusion Assessment Method (FAM-CAM), Informant Assessment of Geriatric Delirium (I-AGeD), and Sour Seven. Three tools were caregiver informed (administered by a healthcare professional using caregiver input): Single Question in Delirium (SQiD), Single Screening Question Delirium (SSQ-Delirium), and Stressful Caregiving Response to Experiences of Dying. Caregiver-administered tools had better psychometric properties (FAM-CAM sensitivity 75%, 95% confidence interval (CI)=35-95%, specificity 91%, 95% CI=74-97%; Sour Seven positive predictive value 89.5%, negative predictive value 90%) than caregiver-informed tools (SQiD: sensitivity 80%, 95% CI=28.4-99.5%; specificity 71%, 95% CI=41.9-91.6%; SSQ-Delirium sensitivity 79.6%, specificity 56.1%). CONCLUSION: Delirium detection is essential for appropriate delirium management. Caregiver-centered delirium detection tools show promise in improving delirium detection and associated patient and caregiver outcomes. Comparative studies using larger sample sizes and multiple centers are required to determine validity and reliability characteristics.
引用
- Rosgen B, Krewulak K, Demiantschuk D, et al. Validation of Caregiver-Centered Delirium Detection Tools: A Systematic Review. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2018. PMID: 29671281. doi:10.1111/jgs.15362
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。