安宁疗护结局的种族差异:种族效应还是机构效应?
未调整模型和调整参与者临床人口学特征及机构随机效应后,黑人入组者的住院、急诊就诊和退出风险均持续高于白人,提示差异不能归因于安宁疗护机构层面的差异。
要点
- 黑人安宁疗护入组者住院率14.9%高于白人8.7%(未调整OR=1.84,95%CI=1.74-1.95)。
- 黑人急诊就诊率19.8%高于白人13.5%(未调整OR=1.58,95%CI=1.50-1.66)。
- 调整参与者特征和机构随机效应后,黑人的住院、急诊和退出风险仍显著高于白人。
核心结论
- 临终照护强度上的种族差异不能归因于安宁疗护机构层面的照护强度差异。
- 黑人与白人安宁疗护入组者之间的照护模式差异在同一安宁疗护机构内持续存在。
研究设计与样本
- 使用Medicare理赔数据识别安宁疗护入组后的住院、急诊就诊和退出安宁疗护。
主要发现
- 未调整模型中,黑人较白人更可能住院(14.9% vs 8.7%,OR=1.84,95%CI=1.74-1.95)。
- 未调整模型中,黑人较白人更可能急诊就诊(19.8% vs 13.5%,OR=1.58,95%CI=1.50-1.66)。
- 未调整模型中,黑人较白人更可能退出安宁疗护(18.1% vs 13.0%,OR=1.48,95%CI=1.40-1.56)。
- 调整参与者临床人口学协变量和机构层面随机效应后,黑人住院风险仍较高(OR=1.75,95%CI=1.64-1.86)。
- 调整后黑人急诊就诊风险(OR=1.61,95%CI=1.52-1.70)和退出安宁疗护风险(OR=1.54,95%CI=1.45-1.63)仍较高。
关键数值与推荐
- 黑人安宁疗护入组者未调整住院率14.9%,白人8.7%,OR=1.84(95%CI=1.74-1.95)。
- 黑人未调整急诊就诊率19.8%,白人13.5%,OR=1.58(95%CI=1.50-1.66)。
- 黑人未调整退出安宁疗护率18.1%,白人13.0%,OR=1.48(95%CI=1.40-1.56)。
- 调整后黑人住院OR=1.75(95%CI=1.64-1.86)、急诊OR=1.61(95%CI=1.52-1.70)、退出OR=1.54(95%CI=1.45-1.63)。
临床怎么用
- 应关注黑人安宁疗护入组者较高的住院、急诊就诊和退出风险,并在同一机构内评估照护模式差异。
- 改善安宁疗护质量需针对入组者层面的因素,而非仅关注机构层面的照护强度差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To determine whether there is racial variation in hospice enrollees in rates of hospitalization and hospice disenrollment and, if so, whether systematic differences in hospice provider patterns explain the variation. DESIGN: Longitudinal cohort study. SETTING: Hospice. PARTICIPANTS: Medicare beneficiaries (N = 145,038) enrolled in a national random sample of hospices (N = 577) from the National Hospice Survey and followed until death (2009-10). MEASUREMENTS: We used Medicare claims data to identify hospital admissions, emergency department (ED) visits, and hospice disenrollment after hospice enrollment. We used a series of hierarchical models including hospice-level random effects to compare outcomes of blacks and whites. RESULTS: In unadjusted models, black hospice enrollees were significantly more likely than white enrollees to be admitted to the hospital (14.9% vs 8.7%, odds ratio (OR) = 1.84, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 1.74-1.95), visit the ED (19.8% vs 13.5%, OR = 1.58, 95% CI = 1.50-1.66), and disenroll from hospice (18.1% vs 13.0%, OR = 1.48, 95% CI = 1.40-1.56). These results were largely unchanged after accounting for participant clinical and demographic covariates and hospice-level random effects. In adjusted models, blacks were at higher risk of hospital admission (OR = 1.75, 95% CI = 1.64-1.86), ED visits (OR = 1.61, 95% CI = 1.52-1.70), and hospice disenrollment (OR = 1.54, 95% CI = 1.45-1.63). CONCLUSION: Racial differences in intensity of care at the end of life are not attributable to hospice-level variation in intensity of care. Differences in patterns of care between black and white hospice enrollees persist within the same hospice.
引用
- Rizzuto J, Aldridge MD. Racial Disparities in Hospice Outcomes: A Race or Hospice-Level Effect? J Am Geriatr Soc. 2017. PMID: 29250770. doi:10.1111/jgs.15228
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。