欧洲养老院与护理院安宁疗护实施类型学应用
该研究通过调查29个欧洲国家的信息提供者并综述二手数据与已发表研究,采用描述性与主题分析,构建了养老院安宁疗护实施的三层次类型学(宏观、中观、微观),并应用于各国数据,发现欧洲各国在实施范围、发展类型与提供方式上存在多样性,宏观与中观因素塑造微观层面的实施与提供。
要点
- 养老院安宁疗护实施可分为宏观、中观、微观三个层次。
- 宏观与中观因素共同塑造微观组织层面的安宁疗护实施与提供。
- 中观与微观实施可由宏观层面支持,但也可在宏观战略驱动有限时发生。
核心结论
- 养老院安宁疗护实施涉及宏观、中观、微观三个层次,宏观与中观因素塑造微观层面的实施与提供。
- 中观与微观实施可由宏观层面支持,但也可在宏观战略驱动有限时发生。
- 理解各国在三层次上的活动状况有助于确定未来实施工作的战略重点。
研究设计与样本
- 研究对29个欧洲国家开展映射 exercise,采用两种数据收集方法:国家信息提供者调查与公开二手数据及已发表研究综述。
- 通过描述性与主题分析调查数据,识别不同结构层次上促进安宁疗护发展与实践的因素。
- 基于数据开发养老院安宁疗护实施类型学,并应用于所调查的国家。
主要发现
- 识别出养老院安宁疗护实施的三个层次:宏观(国家/区域政策、立法、财政与监管驱动)、中观(教育、工具/框架、服务模式与研究等实施活动)、微观(安宁疗护服务提供)。
- 类型学应用于29个欧洲国家数据,显示各国在实施范围、发展类型与提供方式上存在多样性。
- 宏观与中观因素在兩個层次上塑造微观组织层面的安宁疗护实施与提供。
临床怎么用
- 可利用宏观、中观、微观三层次类型学评估各国或机构安宁疗护实施现状,识别活动分布与差距。
- 在宏观战略驱动有限时,仍可通过中观与微观层面的实施活动推进养老院安宁疗护。
- 理解各国在三层次上的活动状况有助于确定未来实施工作的战略重点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The provision of institutional long-term care for older people varies across Europe reflecting different models of health care delivery. Care for dying residents requires integration of palliative care into current care work, but little is known internationally of the different ways in which palliative care is being implemented in the care home setting. OBJECTIVES: To identify and classify, using a new typology, the variety of different strategic, operational, and organizational activities related to palliative care implementation in care homes across Europe. DESIGN AND METHODS: We undertook a mapping exercise in 29 European countries, using 2 methods of data collection: (1) a survey of country informants, and (2) a review of data from publically available secondary data sources and published research. Through a descriptive and thematic analysis of the survey data, we identified factors that contribute to the development and implementation of palliative care into care homes at different structural levels. From these data, a typology of palliative care implementation for the care home sector was developed and applied to the countries surveyed. RESULTS: We identified 3 levels of palliative care implementation in care homes: macro (national/regional policy, legislation, financial and regulatory drivers), meso (implementation activities, such as education, tools/frameworks, service models, and research), and micro (palliative care service delivery). This typology was applied to data collected from 29 European countries and demonstrates the diversity of palliative care implementation activity across Europe with respect to the scope, type of development, and means of provision. We found that macro and meso factors at 2 levels shape palliative care implementation and provision in care homes at the micro organizational level. CONCLUSIONS: Implementation at the meso and micro levels is supported by macro-level engagement, but can happen with limited macro strategic drivers. Ensuring the delivery of consistent and high-quality palliative care in care homes is supported by implementation activity at these 3 levels. Understanding where each country is in terms of activity at these 3 levels (macro, meso, and micro) will allow strategic focus on future implementation work in each country.
引用
- Froggatt K, Payne S, Morbey H, et al. Palliative Care Development in European Care Homes and Nursing Homes: Application of a Typology of Implementation. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2017. PMID: 28412166. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2017.02.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。