急诊科衰弱识别:聚焦可行性的系统综述
该系统综述检索Medline中关于老年急诊风险分层工具实施可行性的文献,最终纳入4篇论文、描述9种工具。多数工具完成时间1–10分钟,但实际筛查覆盖不超过52%的潜在合格老年人,且工具临床可接受性细节报告不足。
要点
- 常用风险分层工具完成较快,多数参与者1–10分钟。
- 实际筛查覆盖不超过52%的潜在合格老年人群。
- 工具临床可接受性细节报告不足,需进一步研究使用场景与使用者。
核心结论
- 现有文献显示常用风险分层工具使用相对快捷,但实践中筛查覆盖不超过潜在合格人群的50%多一点。
- 需进一步了解工具可能由谁、在何时、如何使用,以确保急诊团队可接受。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索Medline中涉及风险分层与实施(可行性、评估或临床医生可接受性)的论文。
- 所有检索阶段由两名综述者进行,所选论文使用CASP队列研究工具进行质量分级。
- 数据仅用描述性统计汇总。
主要发现
- 最初识别约1872个可能相关的标题,标题/摘要审查排除1827篇,全文审查再排除43篇,最终4篇论文纳入分析。
- 这4篇论文描述了9种工具,多数参与者完成时间为1至10分钟。
- 使用任何工具实际筛查的潜在合格老年人不超过52%。
- 关于所测试工具临床可接受性的细节报告很少。
临床怎么用
- 急诊选择衰弱风险分层工具时需考虑其完成时间较短(多数1–10分钟),但应意识到实际筛查覆盖可能不足潜在合格人群的一半。
- 实施前需评估工具在本地急诊团队中的可接受性及具体使用流程。
局限性
- 仅检索Medline,最终仅纳入4篇论文,证据基础有限。
- 数据仅用描述性统计汇总,未进行定量合并。
- 关于工具临床可接受性的细节报告很少。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: risk-stratifying older people accessing urgent care is a potentially useful first step to ensuring that the most vulnerable are able to access optimal care from the start of the episode. While there are many risk-stratification tools reported in the literature, few have addressed the practical issues of implementation. This review sought evidence about the feasibility of risk stratification for older people with urgent care needs. METHODS: medline was searched for papers addressing risk stratification and implementation (feasibility or evaluation or clinician acceptability). All search stages were conducted by two reviewers, and selected papers were graded for quality using the CASP tool for cohort studies. Data were summarised using descriptive statistics only. RESULTS: about 1872 titles of potential interest were identified, of which 1827 were excluded on title/abstract review, and a further 43 after full-text review, leaving four papers for analysis. These papers described nine tools, which took between 1 and 10 minutes to complete for most participants. No more than 52% of potentially eligible older people were actually screened using any of the tools. Little detail was reported on the clinical acceptability of the tools tested. DISCUSSION: the existing literature indicates that commonly used risk-stratification tools are relatively quick to use, but do not cover much more than 50% of the potential population eligible for screening in practice. Additional work is required to appreciate how tools are likely to be used, by whom, and when in order to ensure that they are acceptable to urgent care teams.
引用
- Elliott A, Hull L, Conroy SP, et al. Frailty identification in the emergency department-a systematic review focussing on feasibility. Age Ageing. 2017. PMID: 28200012. doi:10.1093/ageing/afx019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。