痴呆与老年美国人临终共同决策:基于健康与退休研究的回顾性分析
结果显示痴呆逝者预先医疗指示完成率更高、临终需解决重要医疗决策更多、无法参与决策比例更高,且更多由子女担任主要决策者;在有预先指示者中,偏好与获得舒适导向照护的比例均高且两组无显著差异。
要点
- 痴呆逝者预先医疗指示完成率更高(81.3% vs 69.1%),但仍面临更大决策需求。
- 痴呆逝者临终无法参与医疗决策的比例高达78.9%,远高于无痴呆者的48.0%。
- 子女作为主要决策者在痴呆组更常见(63.9% vs 45.6%),提示需加强照护者支持。
核心结论
- 痴呆逝者呈现独特的临终共同决策模式:既有更多预先照护规划,也有更大决策需求和对代理决策者的依赖。
- 预先医疗指示应视为持续共同决策过程的一个组成部分,而非其替代。
- 卫生系统应在预先照护规划之外,补充早期持续照护者参与、结构化决策支持和贯穿痴呆全程的姑息治疗整合。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性、全国代表性观察性研究,使用2010至2022年健康与退休研究离世访谈数据。
- 纳入5389名50岁及以上逝者,具备痴呆状态、临终决策结局及所选协变量的完整信息。
- 痴呆状态依据代理人对死前阿尔茨海默病或其他形式痴呆的报告确定。
- 分析纳入健康与退休研究抽样权重、分层和初级抽样单元,采用调查加权描述分析和改良泊松回归(稳健方差估计)比较两组并估计调整风险比(aRR)及95%CI。
主要发现
- 痴呆逝者比无痴呆者更可能完成预先医疗指示(81.3% vs 69.1%;P < .001;aRR,1.11;95%CI,1.07-1.15)。
- 痴呆逝者更可能在临终最后数日出现需解决的重要医疗决策(54.3% vs 47.2%;P < .001;aRR,1.09;95%CI,1.01-1.19)。
- 痴呆逝者无法参与临终医疗决策的比例显著更高(78.9% vs 48.0%;P < .001)。
- 痴呆逝者中子女或孙子女更常担任主要决策者(63.9% vs 45.6%;P < .001)。
- 在有书面预先医疗指示的逝者中,两组偏好和获得舒适导向照护的比例均高,按痴呆状态无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 对痴呆患者应早期启动并持续推进共同决策,而非仅完成预先医疗指示。
- 应早期并持续纳入照护者参与,提供结构化决策支持,减少临终代理决策困境。
- 可将姑息治疗整合进痴呆全程管理,帮助患者和家庭应对不断变化的临终决策。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To examine whether dementia is associated with differences in advance directive completion, decision-making needs near death, surrogate involvement, and concordance between expressed preferences for care and care received among older US adults. DESIGN: Retrospective, nationally representative observational study using Health and Retirement Study Exit Interview data from 2010 to 2022. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: The study included 5,389 decedents aged 50 years or older with complete information on dementia status, end-of-life decision-making outcomes, and selected covariates, representing approximately 22.2 million US decedents. Of these, 1,010 (weighted 17.7%) had dementia prior to death. METHODS: Dementia status was identified from proxy reports of Alzheimer's disease or another form of dementia before death. Primary outcomes were advance directive completion and the occurrence of important medical decisions during the final days of life. Secondary outcomes included the decedent's ability to participate in decision-making, the primary decision-maker, and concordance between preferences for comfort-focused care and care received. Analyses incorporated Health and Retirement Study sampling weights, strata, and primary sampling units. Survey-weighted descriptive analyses and modified Poisson regression with robust variance estimation were used to compare decedents with and without dementia and estimate adjusted risk ratios (aRRs) and 95% CIs. RESULTS: Decedents with dementia were more likely than those without dementia to have completed an advance directive (81.3% vs 69.1%; P < .001; aRR, 1.11; 95% CI, 1.07-1.15) and to have important medical decisions requiring resolution during the final days of life (54.3% vs 47.2%; P < .001; aRR, 1.09; 95% CI, 1.01-1.19). They were also substantially more likely to be unable to participate in end-of-life medical decision-making (78.9% vs 48.0%; P < .001), with children or grandchildren more frequently serving as the primary decision-makers (63.9% vs 45.6%; P < .001). Among decedents with documented advance directives, preferences for and receipt of comfort-focused care were high in both groups, with no significant differences by dementia status. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Decedents with dementia experienced a distinct end-of-life shared decision-making pattern characterized not only by greater advance care planning but also greater decisional needs and reliance on surrogate decision-makers. These findings suggest that advance directives should be viewed as one component of an ongoing shared decision-making process rather than a substitute for it. Health care systems should complement advance care planning with early and ongoing caregiver engagement, structured decision support, and integration of palliative care across the dementia trajectory to help patients and families navigate evolving end-of-life decisions.
引用
- Xie Z, Hong YR, Armstrong MJ, et al. Dementia and End-of-Life Shared Decision-Making Among Older US Adults. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2026. PMID: 42766994. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2026.106490
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。