文献速递衰弱、肌少症与跌倒安宁疗护

衰弱人群接受辅助死亡实践的现况与资格:一项跨司法管辖区综述

Assisted dying practices for individuals living with frailty: prevalence and eligibility.
PubMed 文献 · Age Ageing · 2026-01-01

本文综述各已立法司法管辖区公开的辅助死亡(AD)使用统计与法律条款,旨在描述接受AD人群中衰弱的患病率及衰弱作为主要病症或共病的情况,并在缺乏患病率数据时判断衰弱者是否可能符合AD资格。仅加拿大和荷兰报告了衰弱患病率:2023年加拿大9.07%的AD死亡与衰弱相关,荷兰3.85%的AD死亡涉及多重老年综合征。研究识别出11个司法管辖区衰弱不太可能符合AD资格、6个司法管辖区严重衰弱符合或可能符合资格、14个司法管辖区情况不明。

要点

  • 仅加拿大和荷兰报告接受AD人群中衰弱的患病率,多数司法管辖区缺乏数据。
  • 2023年加拿大9.07%的AD死亡与衰弱相关,荷兰3.85%涉及多重老年综合征。
  • 各司法管辖区对衰弱是否符合AD资格的立场不一,存在明显监管模糊性。

核心结论

  • 许多司法管辖区对辅助死亡中衰弱的数据报告不足且资格规定持续模糊,需改进数据报告与监管明确性。

研究设计与样本

  • 综述各已立法司法管辖区公开的辅助死亡使用统计与相关法律条款,并据此评估衰弱者的AD资格。

主要发现

  • 仅加拿大和荷兰报告接受AD人群中衰弱的患病率。
  • 2023年加拿大9.07%的AD死亡与衰弱相关(作为主要病症或共病)。
  • 2023年荷兰3.85%的AD死亡涉及多重老年综合征。
  • 识别出11个司法管辖区衰弱不太可能符合AD资格,6个司法管辖区严重衰弱符合或可能符合资格,14个司法管辖区情况不明。

关键数值与推荐

  • 加拿大2023年AD死亡中9.07%与衰弱相关。
  • 荷兰2023年AD死亡中3.85%涉及多重老年综合征。
  • 11个司法管辖区衰弱不太可能符合AD资格。
  • 6个司法管辖区严重衰弱符合或可能符合AD资格。
  • 14个司法管辖区对衰弱是否符合AD资格情况不明。

临床怎么用

  • 老年医学科医生在讨论辅助死亡时,应关注衰弱患者的资格因司法管辖区而异且常不明确。
  • 临床沟通中应向衰弱患者及其照护者说明现有数据有限与监管不确定性。

局限性

  • 仅加拿大和荷兰报告衰弱患病率,多数司法管辖区缺乏可用数据。
  • 各司法管辖区法律条款与统计报告方式存在异质性,限制跨辖区比较。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Despite the high prevalence of frailty among individuals nearing the end of life, there is uncertainty around assisted dying practices (encompassing physician-assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia) in this population. AIM: We aimed to (i) describe the prevalence of frailty among individuals accessing assisted dying (AD), and to describe whether frailty was the main condition or a comorbidity and (ii) where prevalence data are not available, determine whether individuals are likely to be eligible for AD on the basis of their frailty. METHODS: We reviewed publicly available statistics on AD usage and the relevant legal provision from jurisdictions where AD is regulated. RESULTS: Only Canada and the Netherlands report the prevalence of frailty among individuals accessing AD. In Canada, 9.07% of deaths by AD in 2023 were associated with frailty (either as a main condition or as a comorbidity). In the Netherlands, 3.85% of deaths by AD involved multiple geriatric syndromes in 2023.We identified 11 jurisdictions in which it would be unlikely for frailty to be an eligible condition to access AD, 6 jurisdictions where severe frailty meets or would be likely to meet eligibility criteria to access AD and 14 jurisdictions where it is unclear. CONCLUSION: There is a lack of detailed reporting and ongoing ambiguity about eligibility of frailty in AD across many jurisdictions. These findings support the need for improved data reporting and clarity in regulation to provide more certainty to people living with frailty and their healthcare providers.

来源:Age Ageing,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Squeri T, Luk C, Etkind SN, et al. Assisted dying practices for individuals living with frailty: prevalence and eligibility. Age Ageing. 2026. PMID: 42709408. doi:10.1093/ageing/afag275

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。