文献速递老年综合评估认知障碍与谵妄安宁疗护

美国住院长期照护中安全与自主权冲突策略的范围综述

A Scoping Review on Strategies for Navigating Conflicting Rights Between Safety and Autonomy in Residential Long-Term Care in the United States.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Geriatr Soc · 2026-06-16

本范围综述按Arksey和O'Malley框架检索三个学术数据库(ProQuest Social Sciences、PubMed、Scopus),纳入1987至2024年发表的英文同行评议实证研究,最终提取14篇文献。研究将工作人员解决安全与自主权冲突的策略归纳为创新、妥协、倡导、反思、教育五类,其中创新最常用(14项研究中8项),教育使用最少但最常被建议未来实施。作者指出循证策略存在显著研究空白,需进一步研究一线人员如何理解与处理权利冲突及如何推广这些策略。

要点

  • 安全与自主权冲突常见于跌倒预防、痴呆照护、性表达和日常生活安排等议题。
  • 五类解决策略为创新、妥协、倡导、反思和教育,创新最常用。
  • 教育策略使用最少但最常被建议未来实施,循证策略存在研究空白。

核心结论

  • 美国住院长期照护中工作人员解决安全与自主权冲突的实证策略可归纳为创新、妥协、倡导、反思和教育五类。
  • 循证策略存在显著研究空白,需进一步研究一线人员如何理解与处理权利冲突及如何广泛推广策略。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用Arksey和O'Malley框架的范围综述,检索ProQuest Social Sciences、PubMed和Scopus三个学术数据库。
  • 纳入1987至2024年发表的英文同行评议实证研究,由两名独立评审者筛选,最终从14篇文献提取数据。

主要发现

  • 14项实证研究覆盖跌倒预防、痴呆照护、性表达和日常 routines 等主题。
  • 创新是最常用策略(14项研究中8项),教育使用最少但最常被建议未来实施。

临床怎么用

  • 五类策略可为临床照护和政策制定者提供参考,帮助理解工作人员应对权利冲突的多样方式。
  • 可关注创新工具与政策的开发,并加强教育培训的落地,以弥补教育策略使用不足的现状。

局限性

  • 作为范围综述,仅纳入英文同行评议实证研究,未涵盖非英文或非同行评议文献。
  • 研究聚焦美国住院长期照护场景,结论外推至其他场景需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Older adults in the United States increasingly require residential long-term care, where staff must frequently navigate complex conflicts between residents' rights to safety and autonomy. Despite the prevalence of these ethical dilemmas and the potential for legal or professional harm, guidance for staff remains scarce. This scoping review identifies and synthesizes existing empirical strategies used to resolve these conflicts within U.S. residential long-term care. METHODS: Following the Arksey and O'Malley framework, a search was conducted across three academic databases (ProQuest Social Sciences, PubMed, and Scopus) for peer-reviewed, empirical studies published in English between 1987 and 2024. Two independent reviewers screened articles based on their focus on safety and autonomy conflicts and the inclusion of resolution strategies. Data were extracted from 14 final articles to categorize topics and solutions. RESULTS: The review identified 14 empirical studies covering topics such as fall prevention, dementia care, sexual expression, and daily routines. Strategies were synthesized into five categories: Innovation (new tools/policies), Compromise (balancing values), Advocacy (defending preferences), Reflection (team discussions), and Education (training, information). Innovation was the most frequently used strategy (8 of 14 studies), while education was the least utilized but most frequently suggested for future implementation. CONCLUSIONS: A significant research gap exists regarding evidence-based strategies for navigating safety-autonomy conflicts. These five categories provide guidance for clinical care and policymakers to understand the diversity of ways staff can address conflicting rights. More research is needed on how residential long-term care staff understand and address conflicting rights on the ground and how to best disseminate these strategies more broadly.

来源:J Am Geriatr Soc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Perone AK, Zhou L, Glusker A, et al. A Scoping Review on Strategies for Navigating Conflicting Rights Between Safety and Autonomy in Residential Long-Term Care in the United States. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2026. PMID: 42302162. doi:10.1111/jgs.70532

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。