比利时辅助死亡实践中多病共存集群的患病率与趋势:一项健康登记研究
基于比利时2003至2024年6153例自愿辅助死亡(VAD)登记病例,分析多病共存集群的患病率与临床特征。患者平均年龄83.1岁,女性58.2%,平均2.79种共病,CIRS-G均值3.43。识别出5个性别特异性集群,总体发生率随时间上升,最年长组尤为明显。
要点
- VAD请求者平均年龄83.1岁,女性占58.2%,平均共病2.79种,CIRS-G均值3.43。
- 识别出5个性别特异性多病共存集群,女性以肌肉骨骼、精神、心血管负担为主,男性以心肺、神经为主。
- 总体VAD发生率随时间上升,女性肌肉骨骼-精神集群快速增长,男性心脏主导集群呈动态变化。
核心结论
- 多病共存相关的VAD请求具有异质性、随时间演变,并受老龄化和集群特异性疾病模式强烈影响。
研究设计与样本
- 分析2003至2024年比利时联邦安乐死控制与评估委员会报告的所有匿名VAD病例,共6153例。
- 采用老年累积疾病评定量表(CIRS-G,1-4分)评估病情严重程度。
- 识别性别特异性多病共存集群,并用负二项回归模型(含人口调整偏移项)建模时间趋势。
主要发现
- 患者平均年龄83.1岁,女性占58.2%,平均共病2.79种,CIRS-G均值3.43。
- 识别出5个性别特异性集群:女性表现为肌肉骨骼、精神和心血管负担,男性表现为心肺和神经特征。
- 总体VAD发生率随时间上升,最年长年龄组尤为明显。
- 女性肌肉骨骼-精神集群快速增长,男性心脏主导集群呈动态时间变化。
- 语言区和年龄修饰上述趋势,荷兰语男性心脏主导集群初始发生率高但随后下降。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科医生在评估多病共存患者时,应关注性别特异性疾病集群模式对终末期痛苦和VAD请求的影响。
- 对高龄、多病共存且CIRS-G评分较高的患者,需综合评估躯体与精神负担,识别可能反映不可忍受痛苦的集群特征。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Population ageing is accompanied by a rise in complex multimorbidity, i.e. the co-occurrence of two or more chronic or acute conditions. For a growing number of people, this cumulative disease burden results in unbearable suffering. Using 22 years of national data from Belgium, we investigated the prevalence and clinical profiles of such suffering at the end of life, as reflected in requests for voluntary assisted dying (VAD). METHODS: We analysed all anonymised VAD cases reported to the Federal Commission for Control and Evaluation of Euthanasia between 2003 and 2024 (N = 6153). Conditions severity was assessed using the Cumulative Illness Rating Scale for Geriatrics (CIRS-G, 1-4 scale). Sex-specific multimorbidity clusters were identified and temporal trends were modelled with negative binomial regression incorporating population-adjusted offsets, testing interactions with sex, cluster, age group and language region and with and without spline to address nonlinear trends. RESULTS: Patients had a mean age of 83.1 years, with 58.2% female, an average of 2.79 comorbid conditions and a mean CIRS-G of 3.43. Five sex-specific clusters were identified, with females exhibiting musculoskeletal, psychiatric and cardiovascular burdens, and males demonstrating cardio-respiratory and neurological profiles. Overall incidence increased over time, particularly among the oldest age groups. Cluster-specific trends revealed rapid growth in female musculoskeletal-psychiatric profiles and dynamic temporal changes in male cardiac-dominant clusters. Language region and age modified these trends, with Dutch-speaking males showing initially high but declining incidence in cardiac-dominant clusters. CONCLUSIONS: VAD for multimorbidity is heterogeneous, evolving and strongly influenced by ageing and cluster-specific disease patterns.
引用
- Wels J, Hamarat N, González-Hijón J, et al. Prevalence and trends of multimorbidity clusters in Belgian assisted dying practice: a health registry study. Age Ageing. 2026. PMID: 42200481. doi:10.1093/ageing/afag153
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。