同一患者,不同医疗体系再审视:美国、加拿大与欧洲的老年医学照护模式
本文重访20世纪90年代Bergman、Clarfield与Ouslander比较同一老年患者在不同医疗体系照护的经典练习,总结2025年EuGMS大会美、加、欧老年医学会联合研讨会。以82岁共病、衰弱且社会脆弱的女性为例,比较谵妄预防(美国)、跌倒与康复(加拿大)、药物优化(欧洲)三方面照护策略与系统现实。
要点
- 同一82岁共病衰弱女性,在美加欧体系中的谵妄预防、跌倒康复与药物优化策略不同。
- 早期识别的工作力短缺、照护碎片化与共病管理等挑战至今仍相关。
- 新兴模式如Age-Friendly Health Systems、HELP、ACE单元与结构化药物审查展示创新与差距。
核心结论
- 通过对比美加欧三体系对同一老年患者的照护策略与组织结构,可识别可迁移的最佳实践与政策杠杆。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为对2025年EuGMS大会美、加、欧老年医学会联合研讨会的总结性文章,以82岁共病、衰弱且社会脆弱女性病例为讨论框架。
主要发现
- 美国专家讨论谵妄预防,加拿大专家讨论跌倒与康复,欧洲专家讨论药物优化。
- 各报告将临床优先事项置于工作力短缺、照护碎片化与政策挑战等系统现实中。
- 美国Age-Friendly Health Systems与Hospital Elder Life Program、加拿大ACE单元与老年康复单元、欧洲结构化药物审查倡议体现创新与持续差距。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐强调统一老年医学专业能力、嵌入循证干预并促进跨系统学习以优化老年结局。
临床怎么用
- 临床可借鉴跨系统经验,在谵妄预防、跌倒康复与药物优化中嵌入循证干预并关注系统约束。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Health care systems differ worldwide, allowing learning from each other and improving care for older adults with similar clinical profiles. In the early 1990s, Dr. Howard Bergman and Dr. Mark Clarfield from Canada and Dr. Joseph Ouslander from the United States described the approach to care for the same patient in their respective health care systems. Yet, challenges identified then, such as limited access to geriatric medicine care, as well as multimorbidity and system constraints, remain relevant to the care of older adults today. This article revisits the original exercise summarizing the joint symposium of the America, Canadian, and European geriatric medicine societies, held at the 2025 European Geriatric Medicine Society (EuGMS) Congress in Iceland. Using the case of an 82-year-old woman with multimorbidity, frailty, and social vulnerability, experts examined how three systems would manage key aspects of care for this patient: Delirium prevention (U.S.), falls and rehabilitation (Canada), and medication optimization (Europe). Each presentation situated clinical priorities within broader systemic realities, including workforce shortages, care fragmentation, and policy challenges. Emerging models, such as Age-Friendly Health Systems and the Hospital Elder Life Program in the U.S., Acute Care for the Elderly units and Geriatric Rehabilitation Units in Canada and structured medication review initiatives in Europe, illustrate innovations and persistent gaps. By contrasting clinical strategies and organizational structures, this analysis identifies transferable best practices and policy levers to improve geriatric medicine care globally. Recommendations emphasize harmonizing geriatric expertise, embedding evidence-based interventions, and fostering cross-system learning to optimize outcomes for older adults.
引用
- van der Velde N, Supiano MA, Montero-Odasso M, et al. Same Patients, Different Health Care Systems-Revisited. Geriatric Care Models in the U.S., Canada, and Europe. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2026. PMID: 42117876. doi:10.1111/jgs.70478
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。