SHARING Choices 实用试验中基层医疗预立医疗照护计划实践差异
该研究为对 SHARING Choices 实用试验的解释性顺序混合方法分析,评估基层医疗预立医疗照护计划(ACP)干预实践在流程与结局上的差异。结果显示,ACP 促进者覆盖与接受度及新 EHR 预立指令记录、临终潜在负担性照护在不同实践间差异显著(均 p<0.01),覆盖与接受度仅与新 EHR 预立指令记录相关。
要点
- 干预实践间 ACP 促进者覆盖、接受度及新 EHR 预立指令记录、临终负担性照护差异均显著(p<0.01)。
- 覆盖与接受度仅与新 EHR 预立指令记录相关,与临终负担性照护无显著相关。
- 促进者认为实践参与差异与实践关系与团队、ACP 相对优先级及空间等资源有关。
核心结论
- 实践间流程与结局存在显著差异,流程与结局关联不一致,凸显实用试验实施挑战及 ACP 的复杂影响。
研究设计与样本
- 对 SHARING Choices 实用试验干预实践进行解释性顺序混合方法分析,定量评估实践间流程与结局变异,并定性访谈 ACP 促进者对实施差异的感知。
主要发现
- 实践间 ACP 促进者覆盖与接受度及新 EHR 预立指令记录、临终潜在负担性照护差异均显著(p<0.01)。
- 覆盖与接受度与新 EHR 预立指令记录显著相关,但与临终潜在负担性照护无显著相关。
- ACP 促进者感知实践参与差异与实践关系与团队、ACP 相对优先级及空间等资源有关。
关键数值与推荐
- 结局指标包括 12 个月时新 EHR 记录的预立指令及马里兰州严重疾病死亡居民死亡前 6 个月内接受潜在负担性照护。
- 流程指标包括 ACP 促进者与患者/家属的电话接触(覆盖)及促进者主导的 ACP 对话(接受度)。
临床怎么用
- 实施 ACP 干预时应关注实践层面在关系与团队、ACP 优先级及空间资源等方面的差异。
- 未来 ACP 试验应在设计、实施与分析中考虑并评估实践变异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Barriers to advance care planning intervention implementation and impact on outcomes at the patient, clinician, and health system levels are well-documented. Understanding practice-level variation in implementation and outcomes could elucidate relevant contextual factors and potential strategies for improving future implementation. We therefore examined practice variation and associations between processes and outcomes in the pragmatic trial of SHARING Choices, a primary care advance care planning (ACP) and communication intervention for older adults. METHODS: We conducted an explanatory sequential mixed-methods analysis of quantitative variation among intervention practices in trial processes and outcomes, and qualitative interview analysis of ACP facilitators' perceptions of variation in implementation. We evaluated variation in key processes: (1) reach (phone contact between ACP facilitator and patient/family) and (2) uptake (facilitator-led ACP conversations) and outcomes: (1) new electronic health record (EHR)-documented advance directives (ADs) at 12 months and (2) receipt of potentially burdensome care within 6 months of death for Maryland residents with serious illness who died. We examined practice-level correlations among processes and outcomes. RESULTS: Variation among practices was substantial for key processes (ACP facilitator reach and uptake) and outcomes (new EHR AD documentation and potentially burdensome care at end of life; all p < 0.01). Processes of reach and uptake were significantly correlated with the outcome of new EHR AD documentation but not with potentially burdensome care at end of life. ACP facilitators perceived variation in practice engagement with the intervention related to practice relationships and teams, relative priority of ACP, and resources such as space. CONCLUSIONS: Practice variation in processes and mixed associations with outcomes highlight pragmatic trial implementation challenges and the impact and complexity of ACP. Future ACP trials should consider accounting for and evaluating practice variation in study design, implementation, and analysis.
引用
- Dy SM, Scerpella D, Wolff JL, et al. Practice Variability in the SHARING Choices Pragmatic Trial of Primary Care Advance Care Planning. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2026. PMID: 41660694. doi:10.1111/jgs.70341
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。