音乐干预对痴呆与抑郁老年人临床效果的多国集群随机试验
MIDDEL试验在6国86个养老院单元纳入1021名≥65岁痴呆伴轻度抑郁症状居民,2×2析因设计比较团体音乐治疗、娱乐合唱、两者联合与标准照护。6个月时意向性分析751人,MADRS评分各组间均无显著差异,国家间效果异质性明显,无相关不良事件。
要点
- 团体音乐治疗与娱乐合唱均未在6个月时较标准照护显著降低MADRS抑郁评分。
- 国家是效果差异最强预测因素,提示文化与环境差异影响干预效果。
- 无相关不良事件,3个月和6个月急性住院率各组相似。
核心结论
- 国际上,本研究实施的主动团体音乐干预长期未较标准照护更多降低痴呆养老院居民的抑郁症状。
- 国家是效果差异最强预测因素,干预指南与卫生政策需按养老院人群与照护水平的具体情境定制。
研究设计与样本
- 多国集群随机对照试验,2×2析因设计,在澳大利亚、德国、荷兰、挪威、土耳其、英国86个养老院单元开展。
- 养老院单元按1:1:1:1区组随机分配至团体音乐治疗、娱乐合唱、两者联合或标准照护,按站点分层。
- 主要结局为6个月MADRS,在意向性治疗人群中以ANCOVA分析,评估者设盲。
主要发现
- 未报告相关不良事件,3个月和6个月急性医疗住院率各组相似。
关键数值与推荐
- 主要结局MADRS在6个月评估,意向性治疗人群含所有有可用数据者。
临床怎么用
- 不应将本研究中的主动团体音乐干预视为长期改善痴呆养老院居民抑郁症状的有效手段。
- 实施音乐干预需考虑所在国家文化与照护系统情境,并 harmonise 实施方式。
- 未来多站点试验应聚焦更窄的目标人群或情境以减少异质性掩盖潜在效应。
局限性
- 因干预性质,照护人员、干预提供者与居民未设盲。
- 效果在国家间存在差异,异质性可能掩盖潜在干预效应。
- 6个月意向性分析仅含751名有数据居民,非全部1021名随机居民。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Dementia and depression are among the leading causes of global disease burden. Effective and scalable interventions are needed to address the effect of these conditions, and music interventions are a promising non-pharmacological approach. The aim of this study was to determine the effectiveness of music interventions on depressive symptoms among care home residents with dementia in Australia, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Türkiye, and the UK. METHODS: Music Interventions for Dementia and Depression in Elderly care was a large, multinational, cluster-randomised controlled trial with a 2 × 2 factorial design to examine the effects of group music therapy, recreational choir singing, or both compared with standard care. The trial was done in 86 care home units across Australia, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway, Türkiye, and the UK. Care home units were required to host at least ten residents who met the inclusion criteria. Participants were required to be aged 65 years or older; a full-time resident in a participating care home unit; have dementia as indicated by a Clinical Dementia Rating score of 0·5-3 and a Mini-Mental State Examination score of 26 or less; have mild depressive symptoms as indicated by a Montgomery-Åsberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) score of at least 8; and a clinical diagnosis of dementia. Care home units with residents with dementia and depressive symptoms were randomly assigned (1:1:1:1; block randomisation stratified by site, using a computer-generated list) to group music therapy, recreational choir singing, a combination of these strategies, or standard care. The primary outcome was MADRS assessed at 6 months in the intention-to-treat population, which included all participants with available data. Assessors were masked but care staff, intervention providers, and residents were not masked due to the nature of the intervention. Intervention effects were analysed with ANCOVA for the total sample and per country. The trial was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT03496675, and is completed. FINDINGS: Between July 18, 2018, and Feb 1, 2023, 86 care home units with 1021 residents were enrolled and randomly assigned to one of the four groups. 22 care home units with 258 residents were randomly assigned to group music therapy, 22 care home units with 281 residents were allocated to recreational choir singing, 21 care home units with 244 residents were assigned to a combination of both group music therapy and recreational choir singing, and 21 care home units with 238 residents were assigned to standard care. The mean age of residents was 85·6 years (SD 7·4); most residents (747 [73·2%]) were female and 274 (26·8%) were male. Intention-to-treat analysis of 751 residents with data at 6 months showed no significant effect on MADRS scores of either recreational choir singing versus no recreational choir singing (β 0·4 [95% CI -1·3 to 2·1]; p=0·68), group music therapy versus no group music therapy (β 0·8 [-1·0 to 2·6]; p=0·37), or the interaction between recreational choir singing and group music therapy (β -0·6 [-3·1 to 1·9], p=0·63; β represents mean difference estimated from ANCOVA). Effects varied between countries. No related adverse events were reported and acute medical hospital admission rates were similar across groups at 3 months and 6 months. INTERPRETATION: Internationally, active group music interventions as conducted in this study do not reduce depressive symptoms more than standard care in the long term. Country was the strongest predictor for differences in effects, underlining the importance of cultural and systemic differences. Intervention guidelines and health-care policies need to be carefully tailored to the specific contexts of care home populations and levels of care. Future multisite trials should focus on more narrowly defined target groups or contexts to reduce the risk of heterogeneity overshadowing potential effects of interventions. Although music interventions might be beneficial for people with dementia, there is a need to harmonise their implementation and investigate the mechanisms through which they work. FUNDING: EU Joint Programme - Neurodegenerative Disease Research, and National Health and Medical Research Council, Australia.
引用
- Sveinsdottir V, Assmus J, Schneider J, et al. Clinical effectiveness of music interventions for dementia and depression in older people (MIDDEL): a multinational, cluster-randomised controlled trial. Lancet Healthy Longev. 2025. PMID: 41380710. doi:10.1016/j.lanhl.2025.100783
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。