急诊科谵妄筛查保真度的障碍与促进因素:民族志研究
该混合方法聚焦民族志研究在已实施电子健康记录谵妄筛查工具的学术急诊科开展,发现40,818次就诊中6,196次(15.2%)筛查不完整;观察62次 encounter 中25次(40.3%)筛查未按保真度执行。障碍包括优先其他任务、知识不足和语言不一致,促进因素包括照护伙伴提供基线精神状态和护士预先说明。
要点
- 急诊谵妄筛查保真度受环境、患者、提供者和照护者因素交互影响。
- 观察中40.3%筛查未按保真度执行,主因未提问、假设回答或不确定基线。
- 建议教育筛查重要性、培训判断急性精神状态变化及阳性后行动步骤。
核心结论
- 急诊谵妄筛查保真度受环境、患者、提供者和照护者因素交互影响。
- 通过教育筛查重要性、培训判断急性精神状态变化、提供阳性后清晰行动步骤及解决非英语患者筛查实施问题,可能改善保真度。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法聚焦民族志研究,结合结构化谵妄筛查数据回顾、实时筛查观察和半结构化面对面访谈。
- 在一家已实施谵妄分诊筛查(DTS)和简短意识模糊评估法(bCAM)工具的学术急诊科开展,共分析40,818次急诊就诊数据,观察62次 encounter,访谈32人。
主要发现
- 40,818次急诊就诊中6,196次(15.2%)筛查不完整(即未达到保真度)。
- 观察62次 encounter 中25次(40.3%)筛查未按保真度实施,原因包括未询问所需筛查问题、假设患者回答或不确定患者基线精神状态而未完成筛查。
- 障碍包括工作人员优先其他任务(如卒中代码、清洁患者)、对筛查重要性和效用知识有限以及语言不一致。
- 促进因素包括照护伙伴提供基线精神状态信息和护士预先说明筛查以提高患者参与度。
关键数值与推荐
- 老年急诊科指南推荐使用循证筛查工具对老年人进行谵妄筛查,但这些工具常未被充分利用。
- 研究采用DTS和bCAM工具进行谵妄筛查。
临床怎么用
- 急诊科应关注筛查保真度,识别并针对障碍因素(如任务优先级、知识不足、语言不一致)和促进因素(如照护伙伴参与、护士预先说明)优化实施。
- 教育应强调筛查重要性,培训筛查者判断患者精神状态是否急性改变,并提供筛查阳性后的清晰行动步骤。
- 需解决如何对英语不流利患者实施谵妄筛查的问题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Geriatric Emergency Department (ED) guidelines recommend screening older adults for delirium using evidence-based screening tools, but these tools are often underutilized. We aimed to identify barriers and facilitators to implementing an electronic health record (EHR)-based delirium screening tool as intended. METHODS: This mixed methods and focused ethnographic study combined a review of structured delirium screening data with observations of real-time delirium screenings and semi-structured in-person interviews at an academic ED that previously implemented the Delirium Triage Screen (DTS) and Brief Confusion Assessment Method (bCAM) tool. Content analysis of field notes from observations and interview transcripts was guided by the Exploration, Preparation, Implementation, and Sustainment implementation framework. RESULTS: From a total of 40,818 ED visits, 6196 (15.2%) had incomplete screens (i.e., without fidelity). We observed 62 encounters, of which 25 (40.3%) screenings were implemented without fidelity due to (1) not asking the required screening questions, (2) assuming patient responses, or (3) not completing the screen due to uncertainty regarding a patient's baseline mentation. We conducted 32 interviews. Identified barriers included staff prioritization of other tasks (e.g., stroke code, cleaning patients), limited knowledge of the screen's importance and utility, and language discordance. Facilitators included care partners providing baseline mental status information and nurses prefacing the screening to increase patient engagement. CONCLUSION: The fidelity of ED delirium screening is influenced by an interplay of environmental, patient, provider, and caregiver factors. Fidelity may be improved by focusing education on the importance of screening, training screeners on how to determine whether a patient's mentation is acutely changed, providing clear action steps when a patient screens positive, and addressing how to administer the delirium screen to patients who do not speak English fluently.
引用
- Carpenter KP, Bellolio F, Bartolacci M, et al. Barriers and Facilitators to the Fidelity of Delirium Screening in the Emergency Department: An Ethnographic Approach. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2025. PMID: 41045062. doi:10.1111/jgs.70142
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。