文献速递认知障碍与谵妄老年综合评估

ORCHARD-EPR中谵妄患病率、诊断不确定性与结局:与前瞻性参考队列的验证比较

Delirium prevalence, diagnostic uncertainty and outcomes in ORCHARD-EPR: validation against prospective reference cohorts.
PubMed 文献 · Age Ageing · 2025-01-01

该研究在≥70岁急性综合内科患者中,比较电子病历强制认知/谵妄筛查(ORCHARD-EPR,2017-2019)与前瞻性队列(2010-2018)的谵妄患病率、诊断不确定性和结局。ORCHARD-EPR中确定谵妄17%、不确定谵妄11%,均低于前瞻性队列的38%;但确定与不确定谵妄的合并痴呆比例和超额死亡率与前瞻性队列相似。

要点

  • ORCHARD-EPR中确定谵妄占17%,不确定谵妄占11%,均低于前瞻性队列的38%。
  • 确定与不确定谵妄患者中痴呆比例均为39%,与前瞻性队列的35%相似。
  • 确定与不确定谵妄的超额死亡率相似,且与前瞻性队列相似。

核心结论

  • ORCHARD-EPR中谵妄诊断不确定性常见,尤其缺乏关键谵妄危险因素时。
  • 即使合并确定与不确定病例,谵妄患病率仍低于前瞻性队列。
  • 确定与不确定谵妄的合并痴呆比例和结局与前瞻性队列相似,提示筛查有效。

研究设计与样本

  • 纳入两个≥70岁急性综合内科患者队列:ORCHARD-EPR(2017-2019)和前瞻性队列(2010-2018)。
  • ORCHARD-EPR认知筛查包括Confusion Assessment Method和10分Abbreviated Mental Test,谵妄诊断分为确定/不确定/无。
  • 前瞻性队列依据Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders第4版标准诊断谵妄。
  • 院内死亡比值比校正年龄、性别、合并症和疾病严重程度。

主要发现

  • 不确定谵妄2007例(11%,95%CI 10%-11%),其中773/2007(39%)有痴呆。
  • 前瞻性队列731例(平均年龄82.7/7.1岁,痴呆21%),277例(38%,95%CI 34%-42%,均P<0.001)有谵妄,其中97例(35%)有痴呆。
  • 衰弱、AMT<8、感染和低钠血症(SMD均>0.1)在确定vs不确定谵妄中更常见,而合并痴呆(SMD=0.009)无差异。
  • 确定与不确定谵妄的超额死亡率相似,且与前瞻性队列相似。

关键数值与推荐

  • ORCHARD-EPR谵妄诊断:确定(谵妄=是或ICD-10谵妄编码)、不确定(谵妄=不确定且无ICD-10编码)、无。
  • AMT<8、衰弱、感染和低钠血症(SMD均>0.1)与确定谵妄相关。

临床怎么用

  • 电子病历强制认知/谵妄筛查可识别谵妄,但诊断不确定性常见。
  • 不确定谵妄病例的痴呆共病和结局与确定谵妄相似,应予以关注。
  • 筛查发现的谵妄患病率低于前瞻性队列,解读时需考虑筛查方法差异。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性相关内容。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Delirium is underdiagnosed in older inpatients. We determined clinically ascertained delirium prevalence, characteristics and outcomes after implementation of mandatory cognitive/delirium screening via the electronic patient record (EPR) compared to previously acquired prospective cohorts. METHODS: Acute general medicine patients aged ≥70 years in two separate cohorts were included (i) the Oxford Cognitive Comorbidity, Frailty and Ageing Research Database (ORCHARD-EPR, 2017-2019) and (ii) prospective cohorts (2010-2018). The ORCHARD-EPR cognitive screen included the Confusion Assessment Method, and 10-point Abbreviated Mental Test (AMT) with delirium diagnosis = certain/uncertain/no. In the prospective cohorts, delirium was diagnosed by Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Edition criteria. Odds ratios for in-hospital mortality were adjusted for age, sex, comorbidity and illness severity. RESULTS: Among 18 614 ORCHARD-EPR patients (mean/SD age = 82.9/7.4 years, dementia = 20%), certain delirium (delirium = yes or ICD-10 delirium code) was present in 3077/18 614 (17%,95%CI 16%-17%) of whom 1199/3077 (39%) had dementia, and uncertain delirium (delirium = uncertain and no ICD-10 code) in 2007 (11%,10%-11%) of whom 773/2007 (39%) had dementia. In the prospective cohorts (n = 731, mean/SD age = 82.7/7.1 years, dementia = 21%), 277 (38%, 34%-42%, both P < 0.001) had delirium of whom 97 (35%) had dementia. Frailty, AMT < 8, infection and hyponatraemia (Standardised Mean Difference-SMD all >0.1) but not comorbid dementia (SMD = 0.009) were more common in certain vs uncertain delirium. Excess mortality was similar in certain and uncertain delirium and the prospective cohorts. DISCUSSION: Delirium diagnostic uncertainty was frequent particularly in the absence of key delirium risk factors and delirium prevalence, even combining both certain and uncertain cases, was lower than in the prospective cohorts. Nevertheless, co-occurrence with dementia and outcomes were similar indicating validity of screening and research potential of ORCHARD-EPR.

来源:Age Ageing,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Boucher EL, Gan JM, Lovett NG, et al. Delirium prevalence, diagnostic uncertainty and outcomes in ORCHARD-EPR: validation against prospective reference cohorts. Age Ageing. 2025. PMID: 41100407. doi:10.1093/ageing/afaf284

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。