重病住院患者POLST治疗限制与目标一致照护的混合方法研究
结果显示,94%因急性外科诊断接受至少一项操作,75%接受插管/机械通气,44%入住ICU;识别出四个主题,包括POLST不一致照护可能仍符合患者目标、临床医生「修复」心态、对临床轨迹理解不完整及POLST实施挑战。
要点
- POLST不一致照护在急性外科情境中常见,但可能仍符合患者目标。
- 临床医生「修复」心态与沟通影响高强度治疗的提供。
- 对临床轨迹理解不完整可能导致无益照护。
核心结论
- 重病患者接受POLST不一致照护可能仍代表目标一致照护,但存在潜在无益照护的复杂性。
主要发现
- 32例患者中,30例(94%)因急性外科诊断接受至少一项操作,24例(75%)接受插管/机械通气,14例(44%)入住ICU。
- 癌症、脑血管疾病和心力衰竭是最常见的合并症。
- 识别出四个主题:POLST不一致照护可能符合目标;临床医生「修复」心态;对临床轨迹理解不完整;POLST实施挑战。
关键数值与推荐
- 高强度治疗采用一套经过验证的措施定义。
- POLST偏好为有限治疗或舒适措施。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应关注POLST不一致照护背后的目标一致性,避免简单判定为不当照护。
- 在急性照护中需结合具体情境解读POLST,并加强目标沟通。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性病历研究,样本量小(32例),结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: POLST enables patients with serious illness to document care preferences. POLST-discordant care is common, but little is known about the context in which this occurs and whether it represents goal-discordant care. We sought to examine the context in which seriously ill patients receive POLST-discordant care and inform efforts to align end-of-life care with patients' preferences. METHODS: We performed a chart review of the electronic medical records of patients with POLST preferences for limited treatment or comfort measures who presented to the emergency department and received high-intensity treatment (i.e., POLST-discordant care) between April 2015 and October 2016 at a quaternary medical center. High-intensity treatment was defined using a validated set of measures. We used inductive/deductive content analysis to analyze documentation pertaining to patients' hospitalizations and identify themes related to medical decision making and goals-of-care discussions. RESULTS: A total of 32 patients with treatment limitations on POLST received POLST-discordant care. Cancer, cerebrovascular disease, and heart failure were the most prevalent comorbidities. Of these, 30 patients (94%) presented with acute surgical diagnoses and underwent ≥ 1 procedure; 24 (75%) underwent intubation/mechanical ventilation, and 14 (44%) were admitted to the ICU. We identified four themes related to the receipt of POLST-discordant care: (1) POLST-discordant care may represent goal-concordant care; (2) "Fix It" mindset among clinicians contributes to high-intensity treatment; (3) Incomplete understanding of clinical trajectory may contribute to non-beneficial care; and (4) Challenges in POLST implementation limit its utility to address context-specific medical decision-making. CONCLUSIONS: This mixed-methods study of seriously ill patients with treatment limitations on POLST provides context for receipt of "POLST-discordant care" in the acute-care setting and reveals how such treatment may still represent goal-concordant care. Our findings reveal complexities when considering goal-concordant but potentially non-beneficial care among seriously ill patients, and demonstrate the impact of clinicians' mindsets and communication on delivery of high-intensity treatment. Finally, our study highlights the nuances of medical decision-making and the persistent challenge of interpreting advance-care planning documents in acute-care settings.
引用
- Vranas KC, Singh R, Shenk JL, et al. Goal-Concordant Care Among Seriously Ill Hospitalized Patients With Treatment Limitations on POLST: A Mixed-Methods Study. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2025. PMID: 40660462. doi:10.1111/jgs.70014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。