衰弱歧视:一项范围综述探索对衰弱人群的歧视
该范围综述由方法学家、临床医生、律师和患者团队开展,检索五个医疗数据库至2022年6月及灰色文献,纳入144篇文本。结果显示对衰弱人群的歧视以直接歧视(63%)和间接歧视(46%)最常见,且与年龄、残疾等受保护特征的歧视重叠,证据提示衰弱歧视替代、中介、掩盖并强化年龄歧视。
要点
- 衰弱人群常经历歧视,但衰弱本身不受法律保护。
- 直接歧视见于63%文本,间接歧视见于46%,骚扰仅1%。
- 衰弱歧视与年龄、残疾、种族和性别歧视重叠。
核心结论
- 对衰弱人群的歧视在医疗文献中普遍存在,且与既有受保护特征的歧视相互作用。
- 证据提示衰弱歧视可替代、中介、掩盖并强化年龄歧视。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述由方法学家、临床医生、律师和患者团队开展。
- 检索五个医疗数据库(从建库至2022年6月)及灰色文献,纳入144篇文本。
主要发现
- 144篇文本中,直接歧视90篇(63%),间接歧视66篇(46%),骚扰1篇(1%),未报告受害经历。
- 归纳出九类歧视行为主题。
- 衰弱歧视与年龄、残疾、种族和性别等受保护特征的歧视存在重叠。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应识别并警惕对衰弱老年人的直接和间接歧视。
- 评估歧视时需考虑其与年龄、残疾等其他形式歧视的交织。
局限性
- 本文为范围综述,仅描述文献中报告的歧视范围,未提供发生率或因果推断。
- 检索截至2022年6月,未纳入此后发表的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
People living with frailty can experience discrimination, but unlike the characteristics of age and disability, frailty is not protected by law. Frailty is a clinical syndrome associated with ageing in which health deficits increase a person's vulnerability to illness, disability, and death. This scoping review, conducted by a team of methodologists, clinicians, lawyers, and patients, aimed to investigate the extent of discrimination against people living with frailty described in health-care literature. We searched five health-care databases from inception up to June, 2022, and grey literature, to identify 144 texts. The texts were classified by the types of discrimination (direct discrimination, indirect discrimination, harassment, and victimisation) and inductively developed into contextual themes. The median age of the participants was 77 years (IQR 69·9-82·0), and 65·4% were women. The most common types of discrimination were direct (in 90 [63%]), indirect (in 66 [46%]), and harassment (in one [1%]) of the 144 texts, with no instances of victimisation reported. Nine themes of discriminatory actions were developed. Discrimination against people living with frailty overlapped with discrimination based on established protected characteristics, including age, disability, race, and sex. Evidence indicated that frailty discrimination replaces, mediates, masks, and potentiates age discrimination. Discrimination against people with frailty seemed to be both an independent event and one that interacts with established protected characteristics. Future research should focus on preventing frailty-based discrimination and establishing whether frailty should be considered a new protected characteristic by law.
引用
- Braude P, Lewis EG, Broach Kc S, et al. Frailism: a scoping review exploring discrimination against people living with frailty. Lancet Healthy Longev. 2025. PMID: 39805299. doi:10.1016/j.lanhl.2024.100651
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。