衰弱老年人在虚拟病房(居家医院)中实施远程监测为何如此困难?
该定性访谈研究纳入英国42名参与衰弱虚拟病房实施、设计或评估的利益相关者,分析其对远程监测的看法与经验。研究发现远程监测仅被认为适用于小部分衰弱患者,需改变工作方式但支持不足,采购设备不适用,且国家标准化与地方灵活性存在矛盾。结论认为需更多共同设计来指导衰弱患者的远程监测决策。
要点
- 远程监测仅被认为适用于小部分衰弱患者,原因涉及医学、实践和社会多方面。
- 远程监测要求患者、员工和照护者改变工作方式,但该工作性质未得到充分理解、设计或支持。
- 采购实践与服务需求不匹配,导致设备不适用,且国家标准化与地方灵活性之间存在张力。
核心结论
- 在衰弱虚拟病房实施远程监测面临三大挑战:对该人群适用性缺乏共识、临床实践与工作系统设计所需改变的程度和性质、以及设备与标准化相关问题。
- 需要更多共同设计来为衰弱患者的远程监测决策提供信息。
研究设计与样本
- 定性访谈研究,纳入英国42名参与衰弱虚拟病房交付、设计或评估的利益相关者。
- 分析基于持续比较法。
主要发现
- 许多参与者认为远程监测仅对一小部分衰弱患者有用,原因涉及医学、实践和社会多方面。
- 远程监测要求患者、员工和照护者采用新的工作方式,但该工作的性质未始终得到充分理解、设计或支持。
- 采购实践被认为与服务需求不匹配,导致提供的设备不适用。
- 实施远程监测的另一挑战在于国家层面标准化与 enabling 地方灵活性之间的张力。
临床怎么用
- 在衰弱虚拟病房推行远程监测前,需评估患者亚组的适用性并达成共识。
- 应重视工作系统设计与共同设计,确保患者、员工和照护者获得充分支持。
- 采购设备需与服务需求对齐,避免提供不适用设备。
- 需平衡国家标准化与地方灵活性,以促进远程监测实施。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is relatively low uptake of remote monitoring on frailty virtual wards (Hospital at Home) compared to virtual wards caring for people with other medical conditions. However, reasons for low uptake are poorly understood. OBJECTIVES: To explore the views and experiences of frailty virtual wards stakeholders involved in implementing remote monitoring. METHODS: We conducted qualitative interviews with 42 stakeholders involved in delivery, design or evaluation of frailty virtual wards based in the UK. Analysis was based on the constant comparative method. RESULTS: Many participants perceived that remote monitoring was only useful for a small sub-group of patients with frailty for a range of medical, practical and social reasons. Remote monitoring required new ways of working from patients, staff and carers. The nature of this work was not always sufficiently well understood, designed or supported. Procurement practices were also seen to be misaligned with service needs, resulting in provision of equipment that was not fit for purpose. A further challenge in implementing remote monitoring in frailty virtual wards lay in tensions between national-level standardisation and enabling local flexibility. CONCLUSIONS: Implementing remote monitoring in frailty virtual wards is challenged by lack of consensus on its suitability for this population, the extent and nature of change in clinical practices and work systems design required, and issues relating to equipment and standardisation. More co-design effort is needed to inform decision-making on remote monitoring for those with frailty.
引用
- Lindsay RK, Cunnington P, Dixon-Woods M, et al. Why is implementing remote monitoring in virtual wards (Hospital at Home) for people living with frailty so hard? Qualitative interview study. Age Ageing. 2025. PMID: 39820685. doi:10.1093/ageing/afaf003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。