重新构想与重塑预立医疗照护计划
本文指出传统预立医疗照护计划(ACP)以尊重临终意愿为目标,但多项试验显示其并未显著改善目标一致照护、生活质量或降低医疗费用,原因之一是患者未来决策受投射偏差影响而具有易变性。作者提出应从使命、实施与品牌三方面重塑ACP:聚焦教育、分享与准备,融入常规照护,并更名为「预立照护准备」。
要点
- 传统ACP以临终意愿为核心,但试验未显示其显著改善目标一致照护、生活质量或降低成本。
- 患者未来决策受投射偏差影响而易变,应转向持续对话、分享当前价值观与照护目标。
- 将ACP更名为「预立照护准备」并融入常规照护,可明确目的并提高接受度。
核心结论
- ACP需在视角、实施与品牌上根本转变,聚焦教育、分享与准备,而非做出确定的未来决策。
主要发现
- 多项试验提示ACP未显著改善目标一致照护、生活质量或降低医疗费用。
- 患者未来决策受投射偏差影响而具有易变性,是传统ACP效果受限的原因之一。
关键数值与推荐
- ACP新使命聚焦三点:教育(Educate)、分享(Share)与准备(Prepare)。
- 建议将ACP融入常规照护、简化流程并调整激励以促进多方共同责任。
- 建议将ACP更名为「预立照护准备」(Advance Care Preparation)以明确目的并提高接受度。
临床怎么用
- 在常规照护中开展关于患者健康与疾病的持续对话,分享当前价值观与照护目标。
- 以「准备未来」而非「确定未来决策」为沟通导向,简化ACP流程并促进多方共同责任。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Advance care planning (ACP) has traditionally aimed at ensuring that patients' end-of-life (EOL) wishes are understood and respected. However, recent literature raises concerns about its effectiveness, with many trials indicating that ACP does not significantly improve goal-concordant care, enhance quality of life or reduce healthcare costs. This is because patients' future decisions are influenced by their transient preferences due to projection bias. To remain relevant, ACP requires a radical shift in perspective, implementation and branding. First, ACP's mission must be redefined with a focus on: Educate, Share and Prepare. This perspective emphasises ongoing conversations about patient health and illness, sharing of patients' current values and goals of care and preparation for the future, rather than making definitive future decisions. Second, ACP should be integrated into routine care, normalising these discussions. Simplifying ACP processes and shifting incentives to support shared responsibility among stakeholders can enhance integration. Last, rebranding ACP as 'Advance Care Preparation' can clarify its purpose, distinguishing it from EOL planning and increasing its uptake. This rebranding ensures that ACP meets the evolving needs of patients and their families, ultimately enhancing the quality of care and patient satisfaction. These changes in perspective, implementation and branding can transform ACP into a valuable tool for delivering compassionate, patient-centred healthcare, making it relevant to all individuals.
引用
- Malhotra C. Reimagining and rebranding advance care planning. Age Ageing. 2024. PMID: 39447030. doi:10.1093/ageing/afae233
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。