文献速递认知障碍与谵妄安宁疗护

晚期痴呆患者预立安乐死指令的困境解读

Navigating Dilemmas on Advance Euthanasia Directives of Patients with Advanced Dementia.
PubMed 文献 · J Am Med Dir Assoc · 2024-10-10

该研究探讨荷兰医生在处理晚期痴呆患者基于预立安乐死指令(AED)的安乐死请求时面临的复杂性与伦理挑战。研究采用混合方法描述性设计,纳入290名老年护理医师、SCEN医师和安乐死专长中心医师,发现尽管老年护理医师收到最多请求,仅极少数医师实际执行安乐死。各亚组均强调患者当前沟通与参与决策的重要性。

要点

  • 老年护理医师收到最多基于AED的安乐死请求,但实际执行者极少。
  • 所有医师亚组均强调患者沟通对确认当前意愿和评估难以忍受痛苦至关重要。
  • 老年护理医师认为仅当沟通可能时安乐死才伦理上可辩护,专长中心医师更关注判定难以忍受痛苦。

核心结论

  • 尽管收到基于预立安乐死指令的请求,极少数医师实际执行安乐死。
  • 各亚组对晚期痴呆患者安乐死请求的看法存在差异,但均重视患者当前表达和参与决策。

研究设计与样本

  • 混合方法描述性研究,使用包含封闭式和开放式问题的问卷。
  • 应答率13.8%,共纳入290名参与者:108名老年护理医师、188名SCEN医师、53名安乐死专长中心医师。
  • 部分医师有复合角色:老年护理医师兼SCEN医师29名,老年护理医师兼安乐死专长中心医师1名,SCEN医师兼安乐死专长中心医师17名,三者兼有6名。

主要发现

  • 老年护理医师收到最多基于预立安乐死指令的安乐死请求,但仅7名安乐死专长中心医师和1名SCEN医师执行了安乐死。
  • 所有亚组均强调患者沟通的重要性。
  • 老年护理医师认为仅当沟通可能时安乐死才伦理上可辩护,并强调需理解当前安乐死意愿和核实难以忍受的痛苦。
  • 有效沟通被认为对确认请求相关性、识别障碍、让患者参与、建立信任和减轻恐惧至关重要。
  • 医师普遍同意可通过患者表达、观察和家属提供的信息评估难以忍受的痛苦。

临床怎么用

  • 面对晚期痴呆患者基于预立安乐死指令的请求时,应重视患者当前沟通与参与决策过程。
  • 评估难以忍受的痛苦可结合患者表达、临床观察和家属信息。
  • 老年护理医师需关注沟通可行性以判断安乐死请求的伦理可辩护性。

局限性

  • 应答率仅为13.8%,可能存在无应答偏倚。
  • 研究为描述性设计, subgroup variations 使用单变量回归分析,未报告多变量调整结果。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: This study revisited the complexities faced by physicians in meeting due care criteria for euthanasia in patients with advanced dementia in The Netherlands. Despite increasing cases and legal provisions for advance euthanasia directives (AEDs), physicians encounter challenges with ethical issues, including patient communication and assessing unbearable suffering in patients who lack decisional capacity. This study examines the perspectives of elderly care physicians (ECPs), support and consultation on euthanasia in The Netherlands (SCEN) physicians, and euthanasia expertise center (EEC) physicians. DESIGN: A multimethod descriptive study using a questionnaire with both closed and open-ended questions. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: This study explores the complexities faced by physicians in handling AED-based euthanasia requests of patients with advanced dementia. METHODS: Baseline characteristics of physician subgroups were analyzed descriptively, and subgroup variations were assessed using univariate regression. Qualitative data underwent thematic content analysis. RESULTS: With a 13.8% response rate, the study included 290 participants: 108 ECPs, 188 SCEN physicians, and 53 EEC physicians. Some had combined roles: ECP and SCEN physicians (n = 29), ECP and EEC physician (n = 1), SCEN physicians and EEC physicians (n = 17), and ECP, SCEN physicians, and EEC physicians (n = 6). ECPs received most AED-based euthanasia requests but only 7 EEC physicians and 1 SCEN physician performed euthanasia. All subgroups stressed the importance of patient communication. ECPs found euthanasia ethically justifiable only when communication was possible, highlighting the need to understand current euthanasia wishes and verify unbearable suffering. Effective communication was deemed crucial for confirming request relevance, identifying obstacles, involving patients, fostering trust, and alleviating fears. Physicians generally agreed that unbearable suffering could be assessed through patient expressions, observations, and family input. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Despite receiving AED-based euthanasia requests, few physicians proceeded. Subgroup analysis showed varying views, with ECPs emphasizing communication and EEC physicians focusing on determining unbearable suffering. All subgroups highlighted the importance of current patient expressions and involvement in the decision-making process.

来源:J Am Med Dir Assoc,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Coers DO, Sizoo EM, Bloemen M, et al. Navigating Dilemmas on Advance Euthanasia Directives of Patients with Advanced Dementia. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2024. PMID: 39396808. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2024.105300

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。