老年急性恶化患者治疗升级计划中的共享决策:临床医生视角的定性研究
本研究通过半结构化访谈和情境 vignettes 对 26 名急诊、内科、重症和姑息医学顾问及注册医生进行定性研究,探讨临床医生对老年急性医疗场景下治疗升级计划(TEP)中共享决策(SDM)的看法。结果提炼出「不平等的伙伴关系」「无均衡点的选项」「基于共同理解的决策」三个主题,显示临床医生承担为老年患者做出「好」TEP 决策的责任,SDM 在此情境中很少被视为优先事项。
要点
- 临床医生认为患者对未来的健康规划和医疗干预不熟悉,形成不平等的决策伙伴关系。
- 临床医生对适当的 TEP 决策缺乏均衡点,决策受道德感驱动。
- 避免冲突、维护临床关系以及与患者和家属达成共同理解很重要。
核心结论
- 临床医生在急性医疗场景中承担为老年患者确保「好」TEP 决策的责任,SDM 很少被视为优先事项。
研究设计与样本
- 采用建构主义方法的定性研究,对 26 名在急诊医学、普通内科、重症医学和姑息医学工作的顾问和注册医生进行半结构化访谈并附情境 vignettes,采用反思性主题分析。
主要发现
- 提炼出三个主题:「不平等的伙伴关系」「无均衡点的选项」和「基于共同理解的决策」。
- 临床医生综合复杂、不确定的临床信息,与感知到的患者对未来健康规划和医疗干预不熟悉形成对比。
- 决策背后有强烈的道德感,对适当的 TEP 决策几乎没有均衡点。
- 围绕 TEP 的沟通很重要,临床医生寻求对高风险决策的控制,同时避免冲突并达成共同理解。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应意识到在 TEP 决策中患者可能对未来健康规划不熟悉,需关注共同理解的达成。
- 在 TEP 沟通中应重视避免冲突和维护临床关系。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Shared decision-making (SDM) is increasingly expected in healthcare systems prioritising patient autonomy. Treatment escalation plans (TEPs) outline contingency for medical intervention in the event of patient deterioration. This study aimed to understand clinicians' perspectives on SDM in TEP for older patients in the acute medical setting. METHODS: This was a qualitative study following a constructivist approach. Semistructured interviews with vignettes were conducted with 26 consultant and registrar doctors working in emergency medicine, general internal medicine, intensive care medicine and palliative care medicine. Reflexive thematic analysis was performed. RESULTS: There were three themes: 'An unequal partnership', 'Options without equipoise' and 'Decisions with shared understanding'. Clinicians' expertise in synthesising complex, uncertain clinical information was contrasted with perceived patient unfamiliarity with future health planning and medical intervention. There was a strong sense of morality underpinning decision-making and little equipoise about appropriate TEP decisions. Communication around the TEP was important, and clinicians sought control over the high-stakes decision whilst avoiding conflict and achieving shared understanding. CONCLUSIONS: Clinicians take responsibility for securing a 'good' TEP decision for older patients in the acute medical setting. They synthesise clinical data with implicit ethical reasoning according to their professional predictions of qualitative and quantitative success following medical intervention. SDM is seldom considered a priority for this context. Nonetheless, avoidance of conflict, preserving the clinical relationship and shared understanding with the patient and family are important.
引用
- Warner BE, Wells M, Vindrola-Padros C, et al. Shared decision-making with older people on TReatment Escalation planning for Acute deterioration in the emergency Medical Setting: a qualitative study of Clinicians' perspectives (STREAMS-C). Age Ageing. 2024. PMID: 39323400. doi:10.1093/ageing/afae204
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。