执业护士提供居家基层医疗的质量:美国全国医疗保险理赔分析
该观察性研究利用2018年医疗保险理赔数据,评估高强度居家基层医疗(HBPC)使用者(年就诊≥5次)按提供者类型(仅执业护士、仅医生、两者均有)划分的12项质量指标。结果显示执业护士参与近半数HBPC,其质量与医生相似,但仅执业护士组急性住院、可避免急诊就诊和跌倒相关损伤更多。
要点
- 执业护士参与近半数高就诊频次HBPC,患者可能比医生组更重。
- 仅执业护士组流感疫苗接种率高于仅医生组,但预防保健可及性较低。
- 仅执业护士组急性住院、可避免急诊和跌倒损伤更多,但可避免入院更少。
核心结论
- HBPC患者病情复杂,兼具姑息与治愈需求;执业护士提供近半数HBPC,质量与医生相似。
- 仅执业护士组在急性护理利用和跌倒损伤方面表现较差,但可避免入院更少。
- 执业护士组临终关怀相关指标优于仅医生组。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性研究,使用2018年医疗保险理赔数据。
- 纳入574,567名年HBPC就诊≥5次的受益人。
- 按提供者类型分为仅执业护士组、仅医生组和两者均有组,进行双变量比较和logistic回归调整人口学、临床和地理特征。
主要发现
- 37%受益人仅看执业护士,37%仅看医生,27%两者均有。
- 在多变量模型中,仅执业护士组和两者均有组比仅医生组更可能接种流感疫苗,但更不可能获得预防保健。
- 仅执业护士组与更多急性住院、可避免急诊就诊和跌倒相关损伤相关,但可避免入院显著更少。
- 仅执业护士组和两者均有组更可能拥有预立医疗指示、临终前3天接受安宁疗护、在安宁疗护中死亡。
- 仅执业护士组一年内死亡可能性更高。
关键数值与推荐
- 高强度HBPC使用者定义为年就诊≥5次。
- 采用12项质量指标,涵盖可及性与预防、急性护理利用、临终关怀3个领域。
临床怎么用
- 老年医学科智能体应认识到执业护士在HBPC中的重要作用,其整体质量与医生相似。
- 对仅由执业护士管理的HBPC患者,需关注急性住院、可避免急诊和跌倒损伤风险。
- 应充分利用执业护士组在预立医疗指示和安宁疗护方面的优势,优化临终关怀。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: As the US population ages, there is an increasing demand for home-based primary care (HBPC) by those with Alzheimer's/dementia, multiple chronic conditions, severe physical limitations, or those facing end-of life. Nurse practitioners (NPs) are increasingly providing HBPC, yet little is known about their quality of care in this unique setting. METHODS: This observational study uses Medicare claims data from 2018 to assess the quality of care for high-intensity HBPC users (5 or more visits/year) based on provider type (NP-only, physician (MD)-only, or both NP and MDs). We employ 12 quality measures from 3 care domains: access and prevention, acute care utilization, and end-of-life. Analysis includes bivariate comparisons and logistic regression models that adjust for demographic, clinical, and geographic characteristics. RESULTS: Among the 574,567 beneficiaries with 5 or more HBPC visits, 37% saw an NP, 37% saw a MD, and 27% saw both NPs and MDs. In multivariate models, those receiving HBPC from an NP or both NP-MD are significantly more likely to receive a flu shot than the MD-only group, but less likely to access preventive care. NP-only care is associated with more acute care hospitalizations, avoidable ED visits, and fall-related injuries, but significantly fewer avoidable admissions. For end-of-life care, those with NP-only or both NP-MD care are significantly more likely to have an advanced directive, be in hospice in the last 3 days of life, and more likely to die in hospice. The NP group is also more likely to die in the next year. CONCLUSIONS: HBPC patients are complex, with both palliative and curative needs. NPs provide almost half of HBPC in the Medicare program, to patients who are possibly sicker than those treated by physicians, with similar quality to MDs.
引用
- Perloff J, Hoyt A, Srinivasan M, et al. The quality of home-based primary care delivered by nurse practitioners: A national Medicare claims analysis. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2024. PMID: 39291622. doi:10.1111/jgs.19182
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。