医院启动的姑息治疗干预对衰弱成人的系统综述与叙事整合
该研究系统综述了针对≥65岁住院衰弱成人的姑息治疗干预,检索5个数据库至2023年1月30日,共纳入12项研究。多数研究(10/12)为专科姑息治疗干预,识别需求主要用预后判断(如「意外问题」)。证据提示部分症状负担和医疗利用结局可能改善,但异质性大无法定论。
要点
- 识别衰弱住院患者姑息需求主要靠预后判断,而非个体化需求评估。
- 专科姑息干预覆盖需求更全面,非专科团队或可受益于专科支持。
- 部分症状负担与医疗利用结局提示改善,但证据异质无法确证。
核心结论
- 医院启动的姑息治疗干预可能改善衰弱住院成人部分症状负担和医疗利用结局,但证据异质性大无法确定结论。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与叙事整合,检索5个数据库自建库至2023年1月30日,纳入12项实验性、观察性或系统综述类研究。
- 研究对象为≥65岁住院衰弱成人,干预为医院姑息治疗。
主要发现
- 3项研究详述姑息需求识别方法,均采用预后判断如「意外问题」。
- 10/12项研究调查专科姑息治疗干预,其覆盖需求范围广于非专科干预。
- 证据提示医院姑息治疗后在部分症状负担和医疗利用结局上有改善。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准为≥65岁住院衰弱成人接受姑息治疗干预的研究。
- 姑息需求识别采用预后判断工具如「意外问题」。
- 多数研究(10/12)聚焦专科姑息治疗干预。
临床怎么用
- 对衰弱住院老人可用预后判断工具如「意外问题」筛查姑息需求。
- 专科姑息团队介入可能使干预更全面,非专科团队可考虑联合专科支持。
- 现有证据不足以确定医院姑息治疗对衰弱患者的确切效果,需个体化决策。
局限性
- 纳入研究异质性大,妨碍建立确定性效应结论。
- 仅3项研究详述姑息需求识别方法,多数研究未报告识别方式。
- 仅检索至2023年1月30日,未纳入此后发表的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Adults with frailty have palliative care needs [1] but have disproportionately less access to palliative care services [2]. Frailty affects ~4000 patients admitted to hospital per day in the UK [3], making the hospital admission a unique opportunity to assess palliative care needs and deliver interventions. OBJECTIVES: Synthesise the evidence regarding hospital palliative care (HPC) for patients with frailty. Narratively analyse the evidence regarding methods used to identify palliative care needs; types of palliative care interventions studied; and whether HPC improves outcomes. METHODS: Systematic literature review and narrative synthesis of experimental, observational and systematic review articles investigating palliative care interventions for hospitalised adults aged ≥65 years with frailty. Electronic search of five databases from database inception to 30 January 2023. Included studies analysed using narrative synthesis according to Popay et al [4]. RESULTS: 15 465 titles retrieved, 12 included. Three studies detailed how they identified palliative care needs; all three used prognostication e.g. the 'surprise question'. Most papers (10/12) investigated specialist palliative care interventions. These interventions addressed a wider range of care needs than non-specialist interventions. Evidence suggested an improvement in some symptom burden and healthcare utilisation outcomes following HPC. CONCLUSION: Prognostication was the main method of identifying palliative care needs, rather than individuals' specific needs. Specialist palliative care interventions were more holistic, indicating that non-specialist palliative care approaches may benefit from specialist team input. Despite suggestions of improvement in some outcomes with palliative care, heterogenous evidence prevented establishment of conclusive effects.
引用
- Sharratt P, Zacharias A, Nwosu AC, et al. Hospital-initiated palliative care interventions for adults with frailty: findings from a systematic review and narrative synthesis. Age Ageing. 2024. PMID: 39287003. doi:10.1093/ageing/afae190
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。