肾内科医生对终末期肾病老年人使用安宁疗护的看法与经验
该定性研究对20名美国肾内科医生进行半结构化访谈的二次分析,探讨终末期肾病老年人及时获得高质量安宁疗护的障碍。肾内科医生普遍支持安宁疗护理念,但少有人回忆患者实际接受过安宁疗护。两大障碍为:将透析与安宁疗护视为互斥模式,以及不确定谁应管理安宁疗护。
要点
- 肾内科医生多支持安宁疗护理念,但少有人有患者实际接受安宁疗护的经历。
- 将透析与安宁疗护视为互斥模式,导致安宁疗护考虑时机过窄。
- 不确定谁应管理安宁疗护,源于认为肾内科医生和安宁疗护机构均准备不足。
核心结论
- 肾内科医生对安宁疗护的总体支持与患者实际接受安宁疗护之间存在差距。
- 透析与安宁疗护被视为互斥模式,以及管理责任不明确,是及时获得高质量安宁疗护的两大障碍。
- 除Medicare政策改变外,肾内科医生需要接受初级姑息治疗技能培训。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究设计,对一项更大规模研究的二次分析,聚焦安宁疗护主题。
- 对20名美国肾内科医生进行半结构化访谈,主题为晚期慢性肾病老年人的治疗决策。
- 采用涌现主题分析法分析访谈转录文本。
主要发现
- 除少数例外,肾内科医生普遍支持安宁疗护概念,但少有人回忆患者接受过安宁疗护。
- 障碍一:肾内科医生将透析与安宁疗护视为互斥的照护模式,源于对安宁疗护考虑时机的狭隘视野(部分受政策障碍影响),个别情况下对安宁疗护强烈不适。
- 障碍二:肾内科医生不确定谁应管理终末期肾病患者的安宁疗护,认为自身和安宁疗护机构均未充分准备。
临床怎么用
- 肾内科医生需接受初级姑息治疗技能培训,包括安宁疗护指征、与患者启动安宁疗护对话、与安宁疗护临床医生协作。
- 需关注将透析与安宁疗护视为互斥模式对安宁疗护转介时机的影响。
- 需明确终末期肾病患者安宁疗护的管理责任归属。
局限性
- 定性研究,样本为20名美国肾内科医生,结果不宜推广。
- 为二次分析,聚焦安宁疗护主题,可能未覆盖其他相关因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Hospice care leads to improved patient and family outcomes. Hospice use among older adults with end-stage kidney disease (ESKD) is markedly lower than among older adults with other serious illnesses, and the majority of those with ESKD who use hospice enroll in the last days of life. Here, our aim was to explore barriers to timely receipt of high-quality hospice care for older adults with ESKD. METHODS: Utilizing a qualitative study design, we conducted a secondary analysis focused on hospice, a theme that we identified in our larger overarching study that involved semi-structured interviews with 20 nephrologists in the United States focused on treatment decision-making in older adults with advanced chronic kidney disease. We analyzed the interview transcripts using emergent thematic analysis to develop an understanding of barriers to high-quality hospice. RESULTS: With a couple notable exceptions, nephrologists voiced general support for the concept of hospice, but few recalled patients of theirs who had received hospice. Nephrologists' interviews revealed two interrelated contributors to the lack of timely access to high-quality hospice care for seriously ill older adults with ESKD: (1) nephrologists view dialysis and hospice as mutually exclusive models of care; (2) nephrologists feel unsure who should manage hospice care for patients with ESKD. The first contributor was rooted in nephrologists' narrow vision of when to consider hospice (informed, in part, by policy barriers) and, in a couple of cases, strong discomfort with hospice. The second stemmed from nephrologists' belief that neither they nor hospice are adequately prepared to provide hospice care for ESKD. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest that, in addition to Medicare policy change, nephrologists need to receive more training in primary palliative care skills including in indications for hospice, initiating conversations about hospice with patients, and collaborating with hospice clinicians to care for these vulnerable patients.
引用
- Wachterman MW, Sinha A, Leveille T, et al. Nephrologists' perspectives and experiences with hospice among older adults with end-stage kidney disease. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2024. PMID: 38777614. doi:10.1111/jgs.18936
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。