社区老年独立维持复杂干预(CII-OP)类型学:随机对照试验干预措施的定性综合
INTRODUCTION: Community-based services to sustain independence for older people have varying configurations. A typology of these interventions would improve service provision and research by providing conceptual clarity and enabling the identification of effective configurations.…
要点
- 多因素行动来自照护计划是最常见的 tailoring 组件,涉及个体化多域评估与管理。
- 建议改进干预措施组织方面和常规照护的报告质量。
核心结论
- CII-OP类型学为服务规划和证据合成提供实证基础。
- 建议更好地报告干预措施的组织方面和常规照护。
研究设计与样本
- 通过四阶段定性综合开发类型学:系统识别相关RCT、提取干预描述、生成关键特征类别、基于类别分组干预。
- 搜索识别129项RCT,涉及266个干预组。
- PROSPERO注册号CRD42019162195。
主要发现
- CII-OP类型学包含14个行动组件和5个 tailoring 组件。
- 行动组件包括正式居家照护、体育锻炼、健康教育、日常生活活动训练、提供辅助器具和改造、营养支持等。
- Tailoring 组件涉及可能产生照护计划的过程,多个行动组件被计划、推荐或处方。
- 多因素行动来自照护计划是最常见的 tailoring 组件,涉及个体化多域评估和管理,如老年综合评估。
关键数值与推荐
- 行动组件包括治疗患者或直接改善其结局的程序,常见例子有正式居家照护、体育锻炼、健康教育、日常生活活动训练、提供辅助器具和改造、营养支持。
- Tailoring 组件涉及可能产生照护计划的过程,多个行动组件被计划、推荐或处方。
- 多因素行动来自照护计划是最常见的 tailoring 组件,涉及个体化多域评估和管理。
临床怎么用
- 类型学可用于服务规划,帮助识别有效干预配置。
- 临床可参考行动组件和 tailoring 组件设计社区老年独立维持干预。
- 建议在实施和报告中关注干预的组织方面和常规照护。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Community-based services to sustain independence for older people have varying configurations. A typology of these interventions would improve service provision and research by providing conceptual clarity and enabling the identification of effective configurations. We aimed to produce such a typology. METHOD: We developed our typology by qualitatively synthesising community-based complex interventions to sustain independence in older people, evaluated in randomised controlled trials (RCTs), in four stages: (i) systematically identifying relevant RCTs; (ii) extracting descriptions of interventions (including control) using the Template for Intervention Description and Replication; (iii) generating categories of key intervention features and (iv) grouping the interventions based on these categories. PROSPERO registration: CRD42019162195. RESULTS: Our search identified 129 RCTs involving 266 intervention arms. The Community-based complex Interventions to sustain Independence in Older People (CII-OP) typology comprises 14 action components and 5 tailoring components. Action components include procedures for treating patients or otherwise intended to directly improve their outcomes; regular examples include formal homecare; physical exercise; health education; activities of daily living training; providing aids and adaptations and nutritional support. Tailoring components involve a process that may result in care planning, with multiple action components being planned, recommended or prescribed. Multifactorial action from care planning was the most common tailoring component. It involves individualised, multidomain assessment and management, as in comprehensive geriatric assessment. Sixty-three different intervention types (combinations) were identified. CONCLUSIONS: Our typology provides an empirical basis for service planning and evidence synthesis. We recommend better reporting about organisational aspects of interventions and usual care.
引用
- Crocker TF, Jordão M, Lam N, et al. Development of the Community-based complex Interventions to sustain Independence in Older People (CII-OP) typology: a qualitative synthesis of interventions in randomised controlled trials. Age Ageing. 2024. PMID: 38796315. doi:10.1093/ageing/afae102
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。