重度痴呆养老院居民临终住院高强度治疗:混合方法研究
该混合方法研究基于美国退伍军人事务部医院数据,分析2013年去世的重度痴呆养老院居民中接受机械通气或ICU转运者的决策路径。在163名退伍军人中,41人(25.2%)接受了高强度治疗,最常见路径是家属决策困难(18/41),其次为未与代理人讨论即反射性实施(15/41)。研究强调代理人决策困难和卫生系统因素在临终高强度治疗中的作用。
要点
- 重度痴呆养老院居民中25.2%在生命最后30天接受机械通气或ICU转运。
- 最常见路径为家属决策困难(18/41),其次为未讨论即反射性治疗(15/41)。
- 超四分之一患者有预立医嘱拒绝部分或全部治疗,但仍接受高强度治疗。
核心结论
- 重度痴呆养老院居民临终接受机械通气或ICU转运较常见,代理人决策困难和卫生系统因素是重要原因。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,回顾性收集定性和定量数据,使用Minimum Data Set识别2013年去世的≥65岁重度痴呆养老院退伍军人。
- 样本限制在退伍军人事务部医院接受治疗者,从共享电子病历收集结构化信息并构建决策叙述。
主要发现
- 163名退伍军人中41人(25.2%)在生命最后30天接受机械通气或ICU转运。
- 41人中位年龄85岁(IQR 80-94),97.6%为男性,67.5%为非西班牙裔白人。
- 超过四分之一(>25%)有预立医嘱拒绝部分或全部治疗。
- 最常见路径为家属决策困难(18/41),其次为未与代理人讨论即反射性实施高强度治疗(15/41)。
- 4例家属反复主张积极治疗违背临床建议,2例患者偏好信息错误或不可得,2例难以确定代理人。
临床怎么用
- 对重度痴呆养老院居民,应早期识别并支持代理人决策困难,以减少非获益性高强度治疗。
- 需关注卫生系统层面因素,如未与代理人讨论即反射性实施机械通气或ICU转运。
局限性
- 样本仅来自退伍军人事务部医院,以男性为主,外推需谨慎。
- 回顾性研究设计,决策路径基于病历叙述的定性分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: For nursing home residents with severe dementia, high-intensity medical treatment offers little possibility of benefit but has the potential to cause significant distress. Nevertheless, mechanical ventilation and intensive care unit (ICU) transfers have increased in this population. We sought to understand how and why such care is occurring. DESIGN: Mixed methods study, with retrospective collection of qualitative and quantitative data. SETTING: Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) hospitals. METHODS: Using the Minimum Data Set, we identified veterans aged ≥65 years who had severe dementia, lived in nursing homes, and died in 2013. We selected those who underwent mechanical ventilation or ICU transfer in the last 30 days of life. We restricted our sample to patients receiving care at VA hospitals because these hospitals share an electronic medical record, from which we collected structured information and constructed detailed narratives of how medical decisions were made. We used qualitative content analysis to identify distinct paths to high-intensity treatment in these narratives. RESULTS: Among 163 veterans, 41 (25.2%) underwent mechanical ventilation or ICU transfer. Their median age was 85 (IQR, 80-94), 97.6% were male, and 67.5% were non-Hispanic white. More than a quarter had living wills declining some or all treatment. There were 5 paths to high-intensity care. The most common (18 of 41 patients) involved families who struggled with decisions. Other patients (15 of 41) received high-intensity care reflexively, before discussion with a surrogate. Four patients had families who advocated repeatedly for aggressive treatment, against clinical recommendations. In 2 cases, information about the patient's preferences was erroneous or unavailable. In 2 cases, there was difficulty identifying a surrogate. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS: Our findings highlight the role of surrogates' difficulty with decision making and of health system-level factors in end-of-life ICU transfers and mechanical ventilation among nursing home residents with severe dementia.
引用
- Cohen AB, McDonald WM, O'Leary JR, et al. High-Intensity Care for Nursing Home Residents with Severe Dementia Hospitalized at the End of Life: A Mixed Methods Study. J Am Med Dir Assoc. 2024. PMID: 38462230. doi:10.1016/j.jamda.2024.02.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。