蒙特利尔认知评估在多元文化老年初级保健中的文化效度:布朗克斯的经验
研究纳入231名≥65岁有认知担忧的社区老年人,以西班牙语或英语完成MoCA及神经心理评估,由神经心理学家判定认知状态。结果显示已发表的MoCA切点≤23在多元文化人群中假阳性率高达79%,ROC分析提示英语MoCA≤18.5、西班牙语MoCA≤16.5可能更适于识别认知损害。
要点
- 已发表MoCA切点≤23在多元文化老年人群中假阳性率高达79%。
- 本研究ROC分析提示英语MoCA≤18.5、西班牙语MoCA≤16.5可识别MCI或痴呆。
- 西班牙语与英语MoCA得分存在差异,需按语言采用不同切点。
核心结论
- 现行MoCA切点在文化/语言多样的城市环境中偏高,导致高假阳性率,降低切点可能提高诊断准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究招募布朗克斯门诊初级保健中≥65岁有认知担忧的社区老年人,用西班牙语或英语施测MoCA和神经心理测验,由神经心理学家判定认知状态,采用单因素方差分析和ROC分析。
主要发现
- 共231名参与者,平均年龄73岁,72%为女性,43%为西班牙裔,39%为黑人或非裔美国人,49%用英语完成测试、51%用西班牙语完成测试。
- 总体MoCA均值为17.7(SD=4.3);认知正常/主观认知担忧者90人平均19.9(SD=4.1),MCI者133人平均16.6(SD=3.7),痴呆者8人平均10.6(SD=3.1)。
- 英语MoCA平均18.6(SD=4.1),西班牙语MoCA平均16.7(SD=4.3)。
- 已发表切点≤23用于识别MCI的假阳性率为79%。
- ROC分析识别MCI或痴呆:英语MoCA≤18.5敏感度65%、特异度77%;西班牙语MoCA≤16.5敏感度64%、特异度73%。
关键数值与推荐
- 已发表MoCA切点≤23在本样本中识别MCI的假阳性率为79%。
- 本样本ROC分析提示英语MoCA≤18.5(敏感度65%、特异度77%)和西班牙语MoCA≤16.5(敏感度64%、特异度73%)用于识别MCI或痴呆。
临床怎么用
- 在文化/语言多样的老年人群中应用MoCA时,应警惕已发表切点≤23可能带来高假阳性率。
- 可参考按语言区分的较低切点(英语≤18.5、西班牙语≤16.5)辅助识别认知损害,但需结合临床判断。
局限性
- 样本来自布朗克斯单一城市初级保健人群,结果外推需谨慎。
- 痴呆组仅8人,相关比较的稳定性有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Efficacy and validity of the MoCA for cognitive screening in ethnoculturally and linguistically diverse settings is unclear. We sought to examine the utility and discriminative validity of the Spanish and English MoCA versions to identify cognitive impairment among diverse community-dwelling older adults. METHODS: Participants aged ≥65 with cognitive concerns attending outpatient primary care in Bronx, NY, were recruited. MoCA and neuropsychological measures were administered in Spanish or English, and a neuropsychologist determined cognitive status (normal with subjective cognitive concerns [SCC], mild cognitive impairment [MCI], and dementia). One-way ANOVA compared cognitive statuses. ROC analyses identified optimal MoCA cutpoints for discriminating possible cognitive impairment. RESULTS: There were 231 participants, with mean age 73, 72% women, 43% Hispanic; 39% Black/African American; 113 (49%) completed testing in English and 118 (51%) in Spanish. Overall MoCA mean was 17.7 (SD = 4.3). Neuropsychological assessment identified 90 as cognitively normal/SCC, average MoCA 19.9 (SD = 4.1), 133 with MCI, average MoCA 16.6 (SD = 3.7), and 8 with dementia, average MoCA 10.6 (SD = 3.1). Mean English MoCA average was 18.6 (SD = 4.1) versus Spanish 16.7 (SD = 4.3). The published cutpoint ≤23 for MCI yielded a high false-positive rate (79%). ROC analyses identified ≤18.5 as the score to identify MCI or dementia using the English MoCA (65% sensitivity; 77% specificity) and ≤16.5 for the Spanish MoCA (64% sensitivity;73% specificity) in this sample of older adults with cognitive concerns. CONCLUSIONS: Current MoCA cutpoints were inappropriately high in a culturally/linguistically diverse urban setting, leading to a high false-positive rate. Lower Spanish and English MoCA cutpoints may improve diagnostic accuracy for identifying cognitive impairment in this group, highlighting the need for the creation and validation of accurate cognitive screeners for ethnoculturally and linguistically diverse older adults.
引用
- Stimmel MB, Orkaby AR, Ayers E, et al. Is the Montreal cognitive assessment culturally valid in a diverse geriatric primary care setting? Lessons from the Bronx. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2024. PMID: 38196332. doi:10.1111/jgs.18705
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。